Cake Fite

Call Contact the business

Cake Fite Birthday Cakes, Specialty Cookies, Gourmet Cheesecakes, Cupcakes, and More! We offer cakes, ice cream cakes, cupcakes, and more!

Official page for Cake Fite (formally known as Jessi's Cupcakes), a labor of love by Jessi and Josh Fite.

An early celebration for a Halloween birthday girl. Her request was simple: orange and Halloween themed. 🧡👻🧡
10/27/2026

An early celebration for a Halloween birthday girl. Her request was simple: orange and Halloween themed. 🧡👻🧡

10/27/2026

A spooky cake request from a Halloween ghoulie. 👻🎃

We celebrated Mr. Cake Fite's birthday a month early. 🎂 He wanted a dragon scale cake 🐉 for a Dungeons and Dragons day a...
10/21/2026

We celebrated Mr. Cake Fite's birthday a month early. 🎂 He wanted a dragon scale cake 🐉 for a Dungeons and Dragons day at D20 Dungeon, which is an awesome, intimate, and very affordable venue here in Muncie.
Josh asked for a strawberry lemonade cake. 🍓🍋 I pondered that one for a while. I went with my lemon cake recipe and mixed strawberry jello into my lemon simple syrup that I used to soak the cake layers. I made a strawberry filling with fresh berries and lemon juice, and added the last of the simple syrup to my buttercream icing. It's very rare that I get a picture of the inside of one of my cakes, but Josh sent a slice to one of my best girlfriends, so I actually got to snap a pic!
Happy early birthday, baby. 😘

10/11/2026

Fall Cheesecake Menu! 🍁🍂🍁🍂🍁🍂

9" Cheesecakes

Caramel Apple $40
🍏🍎 A cinnamon graham cracker crust, spiced, stewed apples swirled throughout the batter with more stewed apples and caramel on top.

Pecan Pie Cheesecake $47
🥧 Pecan and graham cracker crust, cheesecake filling made with brown sugar, cinnamon, and bourbon, topped with toasted pecans in a bourbon caramel sauce.

German Chocolate Cheesecake $47
🍫🥥 Brownie bottom and a velvety chocolate cheesecake smothered in traditional coconut, pecan, and brown sugar topping.

White Chocolate Pumpkin $40
🎃 Ginger snap crust filled with pumpkin and white chocolate cheesecake, topped with a drizzle of white chocolate ganache.

Classic New York $35
❤️ Graham cracker crust and a rich, creamy New York style cheesecake filling. No frills, just super yummy.

Samoa Cheesecake $47
🥥🍫 Brownie bottom with a New York cheesecake filling, topped with toasted coconut, chocolate ganache, and caramel.
Skip the coconut to have a chocolate and caramel cheesecake for $45

Chocolate Covered Strawberry Cheesecake $40
🍫🍓 One of our bestsellers! A brownie bottom topped with a rich strawberry cheesecake that's smooth and creamy, topped with chocolate ganache and chocolate covered strawberries.

Chocolate Peanut Butter "Beast" Cheesecake $47
🍫🥜 The Beast! The "Monstrosity"! The 9 lb chocolate peanut butter dessert that's a crowd favorite!!! Chocolate chip brownie bottom, a layer of chopped peanut butter cups, and a rich, thick, peanut butter filling topped with peanut butter sauce, chocolate ganache, and more peanut butter cups. You only need a sliver, but we won't judge you for having as much as you want. 😉 Pair this rich cheesecake with a cup of coffee or a glass of milk.

9" 4-in-1 for $50
1/4 Chocolate Covered Strawberry
1/4 Chocolate Peanut Butter Beast
1/4 White Chocolate Pumpkin
1/4 Classic New York

Fall Cake Menu! 🍁🍂🍁🍂🍁🍂

8" 2-layer Pumpkin Spice w/Cream Cheese Icing $30 🎃
I mix my own pumpkin spice each year so you can taste each spice pop on it's own. My cream cheese icing is tangy and not too sweet. 😋

8" 2-layer Spice Cake w/Peanut Butter Icing $30 🥜
A taste of my childhood. This is my mother's icing recipe. You can eat it on cake, on graham crackers, on a spoon, on your fingers, on anything. But it's best on spice cake.

8" 2-layer Carrot Cake w/Cream Cheese Icing $40
This is thr real deal. 6 cups of shredded carrots go into this recipe, along with pineapple, brown sugar, raisins, and your choice of pecans or walnuts. Topped with tangy cream cheese to balance the sweet, dense, moist cake.

8" 2-layer German Chocolate Cake $40
The classic. Chocolate cake with pecan and coconut icing and whipped semi-sweet chocolate ganache.

8" 2-layer Cookies n Cream Cake $35
Chocolate cake Oreo icing, topped with semi-sweet ganache and Oreo crumbles.

10/11/2026

Hello again, friends! It has been a journey of a year. Each time I've started to post a menu, disaster has struck. We've kept our heads up and kept going, but this here's a peek into our last 11 months:
In the midst of my husband's recovery from his accident and two surgeries, our sewage lines collapsed, which caused a minor flood in our house. Plumbers had to tunnel under our slab foundation in 20° in January, or gut our entire bathroom and jackhammer our entire floor. They chose tunneling.
We spent Valentine's Day in the hospital because Josh developed an infection in his broken ankle. I was racing to pack up the house, because, days after we got home, most of our flooring and part of a wall and our bathroom vanity had to be replaced because of the water damage. 😮‍💨
We adopted two adorable cats! I scared one and he bit me really hard and my hand swelled up like a balloon for 2 solid weeks.
Our oven went out. I found out when I tried to serve a cheesecake at a dear friend's dad's birthday and it was liquid. 💔💔💔
We found out that, in an historic flash flood, our hvac vents can fill with roughly 12,000 gallons of water.
I had a severe migraine that caused horrible pain, nausea, and vertigo for 27 consecutive days.
Our oven went out again.
We bought a brand new oven.

So!!!!!! Our plumbing is new. Our flooring is new. Our oven is new. We've each aged about 5 years in 11 months. 😆 I'm posting a fall menu today, and we're officially back to baking again! We've learned that we can handle anything together, so we're stronger than ever. 💪

FNAF meets Pokémon. When the night shift starts, you gotta catch 'em all!
08/11/2026

FNAF meets Pokémon. When the night shift starts, you gotta catch 'em all!

Lemon cake with blueberry filling and lemon buttercream. 🍋🫐🍋🫐🍋  Raspberry coulis *splatters*.
07/24/2026

Lemon cake with blueberry filling and lemon buttercream. 🍋🫐🍋🫐🍋 Raspberry coulis *splatters*.

06/29/2026

I'm really looking forward to the holidays already (I absolutely loathe summer) and I've been collecting recipes and inspiration for piecakens. 😃 Seeing as I love to make cheesecake, I'm planning to do a bottom layer of cheesecake, a middle layer of cake, and a top layer of pie, all topped off with a whipped icing. I absolutely cannot wait! Is it fall yet???

06/28/2026

June was a lot of fun. I didn't photograph and post everything, which is a disappointment, but it was great to be back with my KitchenAid, making special orders for you. I got to make 3 orders for the LGBTQIA community during Pride month, which made my heart happy, too.

I'm going to be testing recipes for angel food cake and working on neapolitan cakes and cheesecakes for July. As always, you can order anything from me, anytime of year, whether it's on the posted menu, or not. ❤️

Today's cake for our friends' celestial themed baby shower.
06/27/2026

Today's cake for our friends' celestial themed baby shower.

Address

Muncie, IN
47304

Telephone

+17657171002

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Cake Fite posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Cake Fite:

Shortcuts

Share