Born Again Baking

10/28/2026

Pre-order your baked goods for this Saturday!

Brookies, apple c***r donuts, chocolate chip cookies, pumpkin cookies, pumpkin muffins, oatmeal cream pies, cupcakes, and bagels!

10/27/2026

Subscribe and save when you sign up for weekly bagels! 🥯

Freshly baked NY style bagels - available every Tuesday and Saturday

Normally $24 dozen, only $20.40 dozen when you purchase a 4 week subscription!
🎉15% savings 🎉

10/26/2026

Check out our "Cookie Platter" menu option for large events like weddings, holidays, business meetings, and birthdays!

🍪Cookies are our love language: what's yours?💝

At Born Again Baking, we hope to bless you by sharing delicious desserts you can feel good about. Everything is made from scratch without any artificial colors or flavors.

10/25/2026

Chai cupcakes are full of Fall goodness and comfort!
Organic Chai tea infused cupcakes with homemade caramel and vanilla bean buttercream swirled on top 🧁☕️

10/23/2026

Making these soft baked pumpkin snickerdoodles and chocolate chip cookies is currently my favorite Fall activity 🍪🎃

Message us or visit our bakesy shop to place an order, with a 2 day lead time.

10/18/2026

The Fall Festival at Pale Fire Brewing Company - Basye was a fun time! Thank you to everyone who came out and celebrated with us!

10/17/2026

Fall sugar cookie decorating kits are for sale!

Ready made - pick up only

Made from scratch with no artificial colors or flavors

$15 each

Send a PM to claim

10/10/2026

Our homemade organic Madagascar vanilla bean paste elevates the flavor of our baked goods 🍪
We also use organic unbleached flour and organic unrefined cane sugar in all our desserts so you can feel good about enjoying your favorite treats.