Underground Pizza

Underground Pizza Underground pizza is your Italian Pizzeria serving traditional specialties and classic homemade pizz Underground Pizza is the best of what Italian is all about.

Underground pizza is your Italian Pizzeria serving traditional specialties and classic homemade pizzas since 1979. The pizzeria that started “in the basement” creates dishes with the finest of fresh ingredients. Come in and enjoy the true Italian atmosphere and the wide selection of regional recipes. Join us! Underground Pizza
3 Hanover Square at 2A Williams Street
New York, NY 10004
212 425-4442
Fax: 212 785-3436
Weekdays 9:00am – 9:00pm
Saturdays 10:30am – 7:00pm

06/08/2026

Asked Ben a simple question:
🥦 How many vegetables should I eat every day?

After more than 44 years serving New Yorkers, he had an answer ready.
Let's just say... it wasn't exactly what I expected. 🍕😂

Watch until the end and tell us:�What's your favorite vegetable topping on a pizza?
👇 Drop it in the comments.
📍 3 Hanover Square, New York, NY�📞 (212) 425-4444�🌐 www.undergroundpizzanyc.com

Your pizza is ready for its next stop: the oven. 🍕🔥A few minutes in the heat, a little old-school magic, and it'll be on...
06/05/2026

Your pizza is ready for its next stop: the oven. 🍕🔥

A few minutes in the heat, a little old-school magic, and it'll be on its way to where it belongs...
Your hands.

Fresh, hot, and made from scratch, just the way we've been doing it for over 44 years.

📍 3 Hanover Square, New York, NY�📞 (212) 425-4444�🌐 www.undergroundpizzanyc.com

05/29/2026

Ben’s making your favorite pizza right now 🍕👨‍🍳�The real question is… what are you ordering?
Classic cheese? Pepperoni? Garlic knots on the side? 👀

Ben’s gonna tell you the truth 🍕�That’s why people love him.Old-school pizza. No shortcuts. No fake hype. Just real NYC ...
05/28/2026

Ben’s gonna tell you the truth 🍕�That’s why people love him.

Old-school pizza. No shortcuts. No fake hype.
Just real NYC pizza made the right way.
Ask him yourself next time you stop by at Underground Pizza 👀

05/23/2026

See this gem!!! We love it!!!

Lunch break? Quick bite? Pizza with friends?We’ve got the space, the slices, and the NYC old school vibe!
05/22/2026

Lunch break? Quick bite? Pizza with friends?

We’ve got the space, the slices, and the NYC old school vibe!

Yes! People say it’s the best and we believe it!� Anthony Pellegrini: Best margarita slice in Manhattan! Best bbq and bu...
05/20/2026

Yes! People say it’s the best and we believe it!�

Anthony Pellegrini: Best margarita slice in Manhattan! Best bbq and buffalo slices in Manhattan!��Help us with your review and let’s more people taste the good NY Slice!

05/18/2026

Behind every garlic knot is a little bit of flour, butter, garlic… and a whole lot of old-school pizza work 🍕🧄
Made fresh, rolled by hand, baked golden, and finished the way we’ve been doing it for years at Underground Pizza

05/07/2026

Ben says it best — this isn’t just a team, it’s family. 🍕❤️

Behind every slice is a group of people moving as one, supporting each other, and making it all happen together.

At Underground Pizza NYC, the flavor comes from the ingredients… but the heart comes from the people.
Built like a family. Served with pride. 🔥🍕

04/27/2026

"The final touch makes all the difference. 🍕✨

Finished by Ben himself — because every pizza deserves that last moment of care before it hits your hands.

At Underground Pizza NYC, it’s not just made… it’s crafted, checked, and perfected.
From the oven to you — exactly how it should be. 🔥

04/21/2026

First time… and definitely not the last. 🍕👀
Give yourself a chance to try something new.

At Underground Pizza NYC, every first bite is the start of a new favorite.
You never know… your go-to slice might be waiting for you right here. 🔥🍕

04/16/2026

3 seconds. One moment. Pure pizza magic. 🍕✨
Did you catch the flying dough? 👀�That’s not just a move — that’s years of craft in the air.
At Underground Pizza NYC, every spin, every toss, every slice is part of the show.

Blink and you might miss it…�But you’ll definitely taste it. 🔥

Red, white, and green — the colors that started it all. 🇮🇹🍕At Underground Pizza NYC, Ben keeps it classic with a tricolo...
04/13/2026

Red, white, and green — the colors that started it all. 🇮🇹🍕

At Underground Pizza NYC, Ben keeps it classic with a tricolor slice that pays tribute to the roots of real pizza. Fresh mozzarella, rich tomato, and vibrant basil — simple, bold, and done right.

No trends. No shortcuts. Just tradition in every bite.

Because sometimes, the fastest way forward… is staying true to where it all began.
📍 3 Hanover Square, New York, NY�📞 (212) 425-4444�🌐 www.undergroundpizzanyc.com

10 boxes. One decision. 🍕🔥When the order gets real, you don’t call around — you go straight to Underground Pizza NYC.Fas...
04/09/2026

10 boxes.
One decision. 🍕🔥
When the order gets real, you don’t call around — you go straight to Underground Pizza NYC.

Fast, reliable, and stacked with flavor… just how New York likes it. Whether it’s the office, the crew, or a last-minute plan, we’ve got you covered.

Skip the wait. Order directly from our link 👇�🌐 https://slicelife.com/restaurants/ny/new-york/10004/underground-pizza/menu
Because when it’s pizza time… you already know where to click. 🔥🍕

04/06/2026

Nothing hits better than hearing it from you. 🍕❤️

At Underground Pizza NYC, every review, every tag, every shared slice means the world to us.

You’re not just ordering pizza — you’re becoming part of the story.

Keep the love coming, keep the slices going… and we’ll keep the ovens hot for you

Say hello to our Sweet Chili Chicken Pizza 🔥Made with:🍗 Tender, seasoned chicken ned chicken🌶️ Our signature sweet chil...
03/30/2026

Say hello to our Sweet Chili Chicken Pizza 🔥

Made with:
🍗 Tender, seasoned chicken ned chicken
🌶️ Our signature sweet chili sauce (the perfect balance of sweet + heat)
🧀 Melted mozzarella cheese
🧅 Fresh green onions for that crisp finish
🍕 Baked on our classic New York–style crust

Every ingredient plays its part — sweet, savory, creamy, and just the right kick.
Ready to taste the layers? 👀

📍 Underground Pizza NYC

When the group is hungry, pizza is the answer.Fresh pizza, pasta, and classic Italian favorites made to feed a crowd — j...
03/25/2026

When the group is hungry, pizza is the answer.

Fresh pizza, pasta, and classic Italian favorites made to feed a crowd — just the way New York likes it.

Perfect for offices, events, and team lunches. 🍕🍝
📍 Underground Pizza NYC

44 years. Same hands. Same standard. 🍕Ben doesn’t rush it.�He doesn’t cut corners.�He just makes it right — every single...
03/18/2026

44 years. Same hands. Same standard. 🍕
Ben doesn’t rush it.�He doesn’t cut corners.�He just makes it right — every single time.
That’s the Underground way.
📍 Underground Pizza NYC

Meet what’s heating up our ovens right now 🔥🍕Introducing the Sweet Chili Chicken Pizza — where sweet meets heat in every...
03/17/2026

Meet what’s heating up our ovens right now 🔥🍕
Introducing the Sweet Chili Chicken Pizza — where sweet meets heat in every bite.

Juicy chicken, a kick of chili, and a fresh pop of green onions…
our own way of celebrating St. Patrick’s Day 🍀

It’s unexpected.
It’s flavorful.
And it’s quickly becoming a customer favorite.

Stop by, grab a slice, and let us know if it’s your new go-to 👀👇
📍 Underground Pizza NYC

03/12/2026

This slice didn’t stand a chance 🔥🍕

Sweet chili heat.�Juicy chicken.�Gone in 10 seconds.
If you know, you know.
📍 Underground Pizza NYC

03/09/2026

A crew came in hungry… and left with favorites 👀🍕

We asked them to name their go-to slice — and they did NOT disappoint.

What’s your favorite at Underground?

03/06/2026

"Underground Pizza is an absolute hidden gem in New York. From the moment you walk in, the vibe feels unique laid back, cool, and everything you want from a true NYC pizza spot. The food? Next level!!! The crust is perfectly crispy on the outside with that soft, chewy inside that only the best pizza places can pull off. Their toppings are fresh, loaded, and full of flavor without feeling heavy.

Customer service was outstanding, too. The staff was friendly, fast, and genuinely cared that everything came out perfect. You can tell they take pride in what they do.

Easily one of the best slices in the city. Highly recommend! 🍕🔥"

03/04/2026

Reviews like this mean more than words can say. Your support helps keep our small business going and motivates us to keep doing what we love every day. 🍕❤️

If you’ve had a great experience at Underground Pizza, we’d truly appreciate it if you shared your review on Google. It helps others find us and helps us continue serving the community.

Thank you for being part of our story.

Office lunch solved.No planning.�No stress.�Just good food that shows up and gets the job done.Feeding a team?� We’ve be...
02/24/2026

Office lunch solved.

No planning.�No stress.�Just good food that shows up and gets the job done.
Feeding a team?� We’ve been doing it right for 44 years. 🍕🍝

📍 Underground Pizza NYC

02/19/2026

For 44 years, Ben has been making pizza the same way.�Not because it’s easy—�but because it’s right.
No shortcuts.�No tricks.�Just ingredients treated with care and cooked with purpose.

Address

New York, NY

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 9pm
Tuesday 9am - 9pm
Wednesday 9am - 9pm
Thursday 9am - 9pm
Friday 9am - 9pm
Saturday 10:30am - 7pm

Telephone

+12124254442

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Underground Pizza posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Underground Pizza:

Shortcuts

Share

Category