Fenwick Pie Company

Fenwick Pie Company Contact information, map and directions, contact form, opening hours, services, ratings, photos, videos and announcements from Fenwick Pie Company, 1410 Balfour Street, Fenwick, ON.

Did you know we make our cream pies on the spot?? 👀 That's right, if you don't see any of our cream pies in our display,...
07/09/2026

Did you know we make our cream pies on the spot?? 👀

That's right, if you don't see any of our cream pies in our display, just ask and we can whip one up for you in under 5 minutes!

We make our cream pie fillings in small batches and ready to be filled in our freshly baked pie crusts, that way you are getting the freshest possible cream pie!!

Flavours available daily are:
Coconut
Banana
Key lime
Lemon
Chocolate
Peanut Fudge (special order)

Please note that because we make these in small batches we do sell out of flavours sometimes, so if you are ever coming specifically for one, just give us a call to confirm we can have one ready for you!

905-892-1289

We are back at the today until 2pm! I have all the things. Except regular Long Johns, unfortunately the heat and sunshi...
07/09/2026

We are back at the today until 2pm!

I have all the things. Except regular Long Johns, unfortunately the heat and sunshine this morning claimed those pretty fast 🫠

Fun times with at the community Market tonight!! Come see us, we are here at the Battle of Beaverdams Park until 9pm!!...
07/08/2026

Fun times with at the community Market tonight!!

Come see us, we are here at the Battle of Beaverdams Park until 9pm!!

Live music, beautiful sunshine, great food, great drinks, great vendors and a great community. Come out and join in all this greatness! 🙃

.

07/05/2026

We are open until 4pm!

I made a little bit of everything today, plus I have a bunch of our $2 raspberry flakies!!

Freezers are full and most of our meat pies are in stock.

We are also restocking our freshly ground Ceylon Cinnamon today you can purchase and use at home!

Have a fantastic day! 🤸🏻‍♀️

We have a sidewalk!!! 🥳🤸🏻‍♀️No more "watch your step" signs on our door!I was very surprised and excited to find our sid...
07/02/2026

We have a sidewalk!!! 🥳🤸🏻‍♀️

No more "watch your step" signs on our door!

I was very surprised and excited to find our sidewalk was poured while we were closed this week!

Our new property owner has really been putting in a lot of work around here updating everything and we are so SO GRATEFUL!!! 🙏

I never thought we'd ever have a SIDEWALK!

I am here for a bit longer today (leaving around 2:30) if y'all wanted to come by and seeeeee it! Lol 😆

Otherwise we will be open at 9am tomorrow!

Happy Father's Day!!! Come get father a pie! Dad's not a pie guy? No problem we got brownies, date squares flakies, tart...
06/21/2026

Happy Father's Day!!!

Come get father a pie!

Dad's not a pie guy? No problem we got brownies, date squares flakies, tarts and of course long johns!!

We also just took our delicious homemade sausage rolls out of the oven if dad is more of a savoury guy!

Open until 4pm!

Have a fantastic day! 🤸🏻‍♀️🎉

Guess who's back.... 📣🥳 FINALLY, we got our hands on some beautiful HUGE peppers for our very delicious Buffalo Chicken ...
06/13/2026

Guess who's back.... 📣🥳

FINALLY, we got our hands on some beautiful HUGE peppers for our very delicious Buffalo Chicken Stuffed Peppers!

We got a fresh batch of these going in our freezer right now and will be available at 10am tomorrow when we open! I will also bring some to the tomorrow and I will be there 8-12!

Don't sleep on these, last year when we brought them back after the winter, they sold out within hours!

You get 2 mega half peppers in tomato sauce stuffed with rice, chicken, onions, carrots, celery, wing sauce, blue cheese, cream cheese AND mozzarella for only $12.00! 😱

Have a fantastic weekend! See you tomorrow! 🤸🏻‍♀️

05/30/2026

Tomorrow is our first sunday open of the season!

We will be open 11-4 tomorrow.

Come see us!

05/29/2026

We 🩷 rhubarb season

Come see me at the St. Catharines Farmers Market today!! We have butter tarts, fruit tarts, long johns and piesAs well a...
05/28/2026

Come see me at the St. Catharines Farmers Market today!!

We have butter tarts, fruit tarts, long johns and pies

As well as a small selection of our frozen entrees and meat pies!

We are here every Thursday until 2pm!

Have a fantastic day!

Address

1410 Balfour Street
Fenwick, ON
L0S1C0

Opening Hours

Wednesday 10am - 5pm
Thursday 10am - 5pm
Friday 9am - 5pm
Saturday 10am - 5pm
Sunday 10am - 4pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Fenwick Pie Company posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Fenwick Pie Company:

Shortcuts

Share