The Wishing Well

The Wishing Well Join us for a great time during packer games.
(234)

Wishing Well togo menu

Sandwiches Appetizers

Fran Burger……………..…3.50 French Fries………………….….2.00
WWII Burger……………....3.75 Mozzarella Sticks………….….…3.25
Chopped Steak………...…3.75 Cheese Curds……………….….3.25
Hamburger………….……..2.75 Jalapeno Poppers…….…….….4.00
Cheeseburger.………

.……3.00 Broccoli Poppers……….....…...4.00
Bacon Cheeseburger….…3.50 Onion Rings……………………..3.00
Fish Sandwich…………….2.75 Seasoned Criss-Cut FF’s…….…3.50
Ham & Cheese…………...2.75 Stuffed Spudz…………….………3.00
Turkey & Swiss…….……..2.75 Buffalo Wings……………….……5.00
Grilled Cheese…………….2.25 Vegi Basket……………….………5.25
Grilled Chicken…………...3.50 Cheese Basket…………..…..…..5.25
Breaded Chicken……...….3.00
Mushroom N’ Swiss………3.75 Tenders & FF’s………………….5.75
Bowl of Soup………………2.75
Bowl of Chili……………….3.25
Friday Fish Fry

Haddock……………………10.00 Perch…………….……l…………12.25
1 ½ Haddock……………..13.50 1 ½ Perch……………………….15.50
Dbl Haddock……………….17.25 Dbl Perch………………………..20.00
Broiled Haddock…………..10.50
Cajun Haddock…………….11.00 Popcorn Shrimp & FF…………..6.75

Combo……………………….12.25 Perch Sandwich & FF…………..6.50
1 ½ Combo…………………16.00 Haddock Sandwich & FF………6.00
Dbl Combo………………….19.50 Pike…………………………………9.00

Seafood Plate………………………………………………………………………….……13.75
Fantail Shrimp, Scallops or Shrimp & Scallops……………………………….…….10.00

Lighter Side Homemade Pizza’s
Not served everyday
Haddock………….…….7.25 16” One topping…………….11.00
Perch………………….…7.25 12” One topping………………7.00
Pike……………………...7.00
Combo………………….7.75 Chicken Alfredo, Meat Lover’s or
Garbage Pizza
12”………….……..8.95
**Over time prices may vary** 16”……………….14.95

05/23/2026

The Wishing Well is closed all weekend!
See ya Tuesday.

05/10/2026

Wishing Well
will be closed today.
Happy Mother's Day

04/05/2026

Closed
Easter Sunday

03/15/2026

Wishing Well will be closed today due to weather! See you Tuesday.

The Wishing Well will be closed at both locations.
01/06/2026

The Wishing Well will be closed at both locations.

12/26/2025

New Year’s Eve Party Wednesday !!Ball drop at 6

12/24/2025
Come join for a great cause!!!
11/17/2025

Come join for a great cause!!!

07/01/2025

Open July 4th
Serving until 8pm
Closed 5th & 6th

05/28/2025

Thank you WAMO and ADI for your support in Appleton!!

05/22/2025

Closed Memorial weekend
Saturday and
Sunday !

Address

2709 E Newberry Street
Appleton, WI
54915

Opening Hours

Tuesday 9am - 12am
Wednesday 9am - 12am
Thursday 11am - 12am
Friday 9am - 12am
Saturday 9am - 12am
Sunday 9am - 8pm

Telephone

+19207344472

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Wishing Well posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category