Coyle's Ice Cream

Call Directions Website

Coyle's Ice Cream The best homemade ice cream and cakes since 1985! Sit in one of our booths or at our soda fountain -
(503)

Islip Location - 509 Main Street, Islip, NY 11751 (indoor/outdoor seating)
Bay Shore Location - 75 Howells Rd., Bay Shore, NY 11706 (indoor)

All the magic of your favorite Italian bakery treat, packed into one irresistible scoop. Our Holy Cannoli combines rich,...
10/25/2026

All the magic of your favorite Italian bakery treat, packed into one irresistible scoop. Our Holy Cannoli combines rich, creamy cannoli ice cream, mini chocolate chips, and crunchy cannoli shell pieces — it’s one of our favorites for a reason! 🇮🇹🍨🤍

10/23/2026

Little ice cream chefs hard at work 🥹 Dates are booking up fast for our Islip event space — inquire now at the link in bio! 🎂👩🏼‍🍳🎈

10/20/2026

🎉 WE HAVE A WINNER! 🎉

Congratulations to Pamela🌺✨ — you’ve won a FREE Coyle’s Party at our Islip location! 🍦🎂 Send us a DM so we can get your party booked!

And to everyone else who entered — we still want to celebrate with you. For the next 7 days, all giveaway entrants can receive 10% off a Coyle’s party when you book with us (to book, all we need is a small deposit).

Thank you to everyone who entered, tagged friends, and showed us a TON of love throughout the giveaway. We appreciate you all!🍦❤️

10/15/2026

Layers upon layers of pound cake pieces and homemade dark brown sugar toffee drizzle. Try it before it’s too late! 🌀👀🍁🍨

10/14/2026

The answer to every problem ever = 🍦🍒🍫

An incredible turnout (and perfect ice cream weather!) for Cops n Cones in Islip. Thank you to ALL who came out. See you...
10/12/2026

An incredible turnout (and perfect ice cream weather!) for Cops n Cones in Islip. Thank you to ALL who came out. See you at the next one!! 🍦🌞🚔❤️

10/08/2026

🍦WIN A FREE COYLE’S PARTY!🍦

We’re giving ONE lucky winner a FREE party at Coyle’s in Islip — worth over $850!

How to enter:
1. Follow Coyle's Ice Cream
2. Like this post
3. Tag 3 people who you think would love to learn more about Coyle’s events, AND tell us the name of someone you’d love to celebrate 🎉

Once you comment, check your DMs to complete your entry! Giveaway closes at midnight on October 15th.

Good luck! 🎉🍦

10/07/2026

When we say Cops n Cones, we mean the ice cream kind… 👀🚨🍦

A day off from school calls for a little extra fun! Cops n Cones is hitting our new Islip location and we can’t wait to see you there — kids 12 and under get a FREE soft serve ice cream!

📍539 Main St, Islip
🗓️ October 12, 2026
⏰ 12-2PM

Cops n Cones is back — come out to our Islip location this Columbus Day and enjoy FREE soft serve ice cream (for kids 12...
10/05/2026

Cops n Cones is back — come out to our Islip location this Columbus Day and enjoy FREE soft serve ice cream (for kids 12 and under) with our local police officers! 🚔🍦🍁

October is here — and we’re introducing our take on Sticky Toffee Pudding. Homemade dark brown sugar toffee ripples and...
10/01/2026

October is here — and we’re introducing our take on Sticky Toffee Pudding.

Homemade dark brown sugar toffee ripples and pound cake pieces layered throughout for the perfect sweet, rich, fluffy and gooey bite.

A little taste of fall, the Coyle’s way. Here through October only! 🤎🍦🍁

Address

75 Howells Road
Bay Shore, NY
11706

Opening Hours

Monday 3pm - 10pm
Tuesday 12pm - 10pm
Wednesday 12pm - 10pm
Thursday 12pm - 10pm
Friday 12pm - 11pm
Saturday 12pm - 11pm
Sunday 12pm - 10pm

Telephone

+16316662229

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Coyle's Ice Cream posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category