The Penny Pub

The Penny Pub Long-standing neighborhood watering hole offering pub fare, drinks, live entertainment, and karaoke.
(257)

Bay Shore Sundays are best spent with a pint of Guinness in hand. Join us for Guinness Club Night tonight at 8PM.
06/07/2026

Bay Shore Sundays are best spent with a pint of Guinness in hand. Join us for Guinness Club Night tonight at 8PM.

06/06/2026

Here's to nights that always turn into "just one more drink."

Some nights just aren’t ready to end, good thing our kitchen is open late, and we’re open till 3AM every day!
06/06/2026

Some nights just aren’t ready to end, good thing our kitchen is open late, and we’re open till 3AM every day!

The kind of drink meant for slow sips and long conversations.
06/04/2026

The kind of drink meant for slow sips and long conversations.

The whiskey’s flowing, and the stories are getting better by the round.
06/03/2026

The whiskey’s flowing, and the stories are getting better by the round.

The pints are poured, and the bingo balls are rolling. Tonight at 8PM.
06/02/2026

The pints are poured, and the bingo balls are rolling. Tonight at 8PM.

Think your team has what it takes? Come test your knowledge at Night Trivia every Monday at 8PM.
06/01/2026

Think your team has what it takes? Come test your knowledge at Night Trivia every Monday at 8PM.

05/31/2026

Sunday Funday is just better at the Penny Pub! Hang with us on our outdoor patio! ☀️

Tomorrow’s plans? ⚽🍺 The Penny Pub opens at 11AM this Saturday for the Arsenal game kicking off at 12PM. Come early, gra...
05/29/2026

Tomorrow’s plans? ⚽🍺 The Penny Pub opens at 11AM this Saturday for the Arsenal game kicking off at 12PM. Come early, grab a cold one, and watch the action with fellow supporters in true pub fashion.

When everything else closes, we’re still going.Open till 3AM.
05/29/2026

When everything else closes, we’re still going.
Open till 3AM.

Address

79 W Main Street
Bay Shore, NY
11706

Opening Hours

Monday 12pm - 4am
Tuesday 12pm - 4am
Wednesday 12pm - 4am
Thursday 12pm - 4am
Friday 12pm - 4am
Saturday 12pm - 4am
Sunday 10am - 4am

Telephone

+16319694061

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Penny Pub posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Penny Pub:

Shortcuts

Share

Category