Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe

Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe Bagel Island specializes in New York Style Bagels made fresh daily along with a full line of breakfast and lunch options.

Some things are just better when they’re made fresh. 🥯🤍Every bagel, every sandwich, and every cup of coffee is served wi...
07/12/2026

Some things are just better when they’re made fresh. 🥯🤍

Every bagel, every sandwich, and every cup of coffee is served with the kind of care that keeps people coming back. Whether you’re grabbing breakfast on the go, meeting a friend for lunch, or picking up your weekend favorite, we’re so grateful to be part of your day.

There’s nothing fancy about doing the little things well—but we believe that’s what makes all the difference.

Stop by today, grab your favorite (or try something new!), and let us make your day a little more delicious. See you soon! ☕🥯

Thank you to everyone who passed through our door for the July 4th weekend! We appreciate you making us a part of your c...
07/10/2026

Thank you to everyone who passed through our door for the July 4th weekend! We appreciate you making us a part of your celebration!
We will be closed this weekend for a little get away before we head into the second part of summer. 🥯🏝️🇺🇸🥰☀️😎

Some bagels are just too good not to photograph. 📸🥯Fresh-baked every day, piled high with your favorite ingredients, and...
07/08/2026

Some bagels are just too good not to photograph. 📸🥯

Fresh-baked every day, piled high with your favorite ingredients, and made with the same homemade quality that’s kept our customers coming back. Whether you’re here for your go-to breakfast bagel or a stacked lunch sandwich, every bite is worth the hype—and maybe a spot on your camera roll.

Go ahead… snap the pic, then enjoy every bite. We can’t wait to see what you’re ordering! Tag us in your photos and stop by Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe today. 🤍

Stars, stripes, sunshine… and fresh bagels. 🇺🇸🥯No matter what your Fourth of July weekend looks like, we’re here to help...
07/03/2026

Stars, stripes, sunshine… and fresh bagels. 🇺🇸🥯

No matter what your Fourth of July weekend looks like, we’re here to help kick it off with a delicious breakfast, fresh coffee, or your favorite homemade sandwich.

✨ We’re open our regular hours all weekend:
Friday: 7 AM–2 PM
Saturday: 7 AM–2 PM
Sunday: 7 AM–1 PM

Stop in before the lake, the parade, the cookout, or wherever the weekend takes you. We can’t wait to see you!

Wishing everyone a safe, happy, and delicious Fourth of July weekend! ❤️🤍💙

You’ve seen the process... now taste the resultBagel Island today for fresh, homemade bagels done right.🥯
06/26/2026

You’ve seen the process... now taste the result
Bagel Island today for fresh, homemade bagels done right.🥯

06/24/2026

Happy Wednesday!
We will be closing today at 1pm
for maintenance

Built for the Boat. Made with Heart. ⚓️Every sandwich that leaves our kitchen is made with intention. Fresh ingredients,...
06/23/2026

Built for the Boat. Made with Heart. ⚓️

Every sandwich that leaves our kitchen is made with intention. Fresh ingredients, attention to detail, and the kind of care you can taste in every bite. Whether you’re grabbing lunch between adventures or fueling up for the day ahead, we’re proud to serve food that feels simple, satisfying, and made for the moments that matter.

Thank you for letting us be part of your table (or your boat 😉). We’re grateful for every order and every familiar face.

Come hungry. Leave happy.

05/27/2026

We will be closed Wednesday due to an equipment issue.
We should be up and running by tomorrow.
Our apologies for any inconvenience.

04/24/2026

YAY!
WE ARE OPEN!
🥯🏝️🥳😄

04/11/2026

Happy Saturday!
Just a reminder we will be closed today.
Good luck to Jason and Greg!
We will be back at it Sunday!

Address

205 Key Deer Boulevard
Big Pine Key, FL
33043

Opening Hours

Wednesday 7am - 2pm
Thursday 7am - 2pm
Friday 7am - 2pm
Saturday 7am - 2pm
Sunday 7am - 1pm

Telephone

+13058729912

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe:

Shortcuts

Share