What are the opening hours?

Monday 7am - 5pm Tuesday 7am - 5pm Wednesday 7am - 5pm Thursday 7am - 5pm Friday 7am - 5pm Saturday 7am - 5pm Sunday 7am - 5pm

Butler Bakeshop

Home
United States
New York, NY
Butler Bakeshop

Directions Website

An all-day cafe and neighborhood favorite, Butler offers espresso, pasties, and a la carte menu.

95 S 5th St, Brooklyn NY 11249
101 N 8th St, Brooklyn NY 11211
40 Water St, Brooklyn NY 11201
177 Lafayette St, New York, NY 10013

11/12/2026

If you seek shelter from the rain and coffee fir the soul…

11/07/2026

Pie season is officially here. 🍂🥧 Reserve your Thanksgiving Pies online through 11/22 for holiday pickup!

This year’s pies —
🎃 Pumpkin Praline with praline pecans & cream cheese frosting
🍎 Salted Caramel Apple with salted miso caramel & buttery crumble

Details —
🍰 Slices In-Store:
- Available starting 11/9
📍 Pickups:
- SWB & Dumbo: Tues 11/24 (all day) & Wed 11/25 (before 2pm)
- SoHo: Tues 11/24 (by 12pm ONLY — closed 11/25 for renovations)

11/04/2026

Just a beautiful day…

11/02/2026

Thanksgiving Pies pre-orders are now LIVE online! 🍂🥧

🎃 Pumpkin Praline Pie: A classic fall and Thanksgiving combination that combines a smooth, spiced pumpkin custard with caramelized praline pecans . Rich, aromatic and perfectly balanced. Finished with a house made cream cheese frosting.

🍎 Salted Caramel Apple Pie: A traditional apple crumble pie but with a twist. Freshly diced apples tossed in cinnamon and brown sugar paired with a house made salted miso caramel sauce. Topped with a buttery crumble topping.

Pick-up in SWB & DUMBO:
Tuesday 11/24 prior to closing hours
Wednesday 11/25, by 2pm

Pick-up in SOHO ONLY:
Tuesday 11/24, by 12pm
Closed Wednesday 11/25 for renovations

Secure your whole pies now through 11/22 for holiday pickup. Slices will only be available in-store from 11/9.

10/28/2026

Did someone say “sausage rolls”?? 🤤

10/25/2026

Another day of beautiful fall weather incoming…

10/20/2026

Are you excited for the season change?

10/16/2026

Happy Friday to my caffeine loving squad 🫶🏼

10/13/2026

Our new fall/winter menu just dropped in South Williamsburg today!

It’s also already available in Dumbo and SoHo.

10/12/2026

Come for the coffee, come for the pastries and come for the free peanut butter treats! 🦴

📸 Finnley the City Golden✨

Address

95 S 5th Street
New York, NY
11249

Opening Hours

Monday	7am - 5pm
Tuesday	7am - 5pm
Wednesday	7am - 5pm
Thursday	7am - 5pm
Friday	7am - 5pm
Saturday	7am - 5pm
Sunday	7am - 5pm

Website

http://www.butler-nyc.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Butler Bakeshop posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.