Afternoon Scoop

Afternoon Scoop Located at 266 State St in downtown Carthage NY. A frozen desert experience like no other!
(1)

Try one of our unique Sundae creations, Floats, Shakes, Soft serve, and Hard Ice cream flavors! Located in the same building as the Morning Ritual Cafe, we have a diverse selection of Perrys hard ice cream flavors, to include ALL of their dairy free options! Our locally sourced soft serve is 2nd to none, and our donut and brownie specialty sundaes are sure to impress! Try one of our milkshakes or

affogatos as they have been labeled by some as "the best in town" OR try one of our many float options!

After much consideration, we want to share an update with our community.Due to ongoing lease and civil matters, we have ...
05/01/2026

After much consideration, we want to share an update with our community.

Due to ongoing lease and civil matters, we have made the difficult decision to close our doors at this location. This is not the ending we hoped for, and it's incredibly hard to say goodbye to the space where so many memories were made. However, this isn't the end of our story.

Our ice cream shop is now FOR SALE - including equipment, brand, recipes, the opportunity to take over a profitable business, and the opportunity to continue serving the community that has supported us from day one. We would love to see someone carry this forward and keep the spirit of the shop alive.

If you or someone you know may be interested, please reach out to us directly for more details.

Thank you for every scoop, every smile, and every bit of support you've shown us. ❤️

To our loyal supporters: We’ll be temporarily closed while we work through a lease issue at our current location. We’re ...
04/17/2026

To our loyal supporters: We’ll be temporarily closed while we work through a lease issue at our current location. We’re hopeful this will be resolved quickly and look forward to serving you again soon!

04/16/2026

And we love the support from all of you 🍦"addicts" 😜
🔹️
266 State St Carthage
🔹️

With so many flavor options to choose from, sometimes a flight isn't good enough. Try a SUPER flight!...Your choice of 6...
04/15/2026

With so many flavor options to choose from, sometimes a flight isn't good enough. Try a SUPER flight!...Your choice of 6🍦flavors!
Open 7 days a week!
🔹️
266 State St Carthage
🔹️

🍌 The "Banana Bliss" 😍Yes, theres a whole Banana sliced up and mixed in there. Look close to find it OR, get one and fin...
04/14/2026

🍌 The "Banana Bliss" 😍
Yes, theres a whole Banana sliced up and mixed in there. Look close to find it OR, get one and find it with your own spoon 😉
🔹️
266 State St Carthage
Open today 4pm-8pm
🔹️

Try a flight! 4 scoops, any flavor🍦🍨🔹️266 State St Carthage Open today 4pm-8pm 🔹️
04/13/2026

Try a flight! 4 scoops, any flavor🍦🍨
🔹️
266 State St Carthage
Open today 4pm-8pm
🔹️

04/12/2026

Open today!
4pm-8pm

Maverick & Reese will be here this afternoon selling cookies and Lemonade. They told me they wanted to start their own b...
04/11/2026

Maverick & Reese will be here this afternoon selling cookies and Lemonade. They told me they wanted to start their own business so they could save money for a car and a house when they grow up ❤️...They're probably going to crush my ice cream sales but how does a father say no to THAT!? 😂🤷‍♂️
We will be open 3pm-9pm today. They will set up shop at 3pm and be here until they sell out 👍
🔹️
266 State St Carthage
🔹️

Yes, we make DIARY FREE SHAKES and we have multiple flavor options available!😍➡️Remember, we are open until 9pm this eve...
04/10/2026

Yes, we make DIARY FREE SHAKES and we have multiple flavor options available!😍
➡️Remember, we are open until 9pm this evening and tomorrow (Sat) evening!
🔹️
266 State St Carthage
Open today 4pm-9pm
🔹️

Pies and ice cream sandwiches are still available in the "Grab & Go" freezer! Yes, we have SNICKERS PIES available👇🔹️266...
04/09/2026

Pies and ice cream sandwiches are still available in the "Grab & Go" freezer!
Yes, we have SNICKERS PIES available👇
🔹️
266 State St Carthage
Open today 4pm-8pm
🔹️

How about a "Birch Beer" float? 😍🔹️266 State St Carthage 🔹️
04/08/2026

How about a "Birch Beer" float? 😍
🔹️
266 State St Carthage
🔹️

Address

266 State St
Carthage, NY
13619

Opening Hours

Monday 4pm - 8pm
Tuesday 4pm - 8pm
Wednesday 4pm - 8pm
Thursday 4pm - 8pm
Friday 4pm - 9pm
Saturday 3pm - 9pm
Sunday 4pm - 8pm

Telephone

+13152226721

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Afternoon Scoop posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Afternoon Scoop:

Shortcuts

Share

Category