Goodfellas Pizzeria - Short North

Call Directions Website Contact the business

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Short North Hand-tossed NY-style slices & pies and a full craft cocktail bar in the Short North Arts District of Columbus. $10 Lunch, ½-price 12” Mondays. Open late.

Dine-in & carryout.

We don't just do pizza around here. 🤌🍕Big slices, cold drinks, arcade games, patio hangs, and a hidden bourbon lounge. O...
10/25/2026

We don't just do pizza around here. 🤌🍕

Big slices, cold drinks, arcade games, patio hangs, and a hidden bourbon lounge. Our Baxter Ave crew has the whole operation covered.

New Merch. Low Prices. Free Shipping.
10/24/2026

New Merch. Low Prices. Free Shipping.

10/23/2026

Once a Wildcat, always a Wildcat. 💙🏈

Former UK running back JoJo Kemp is still making an impact in Lexington through Change The Game (CTG) Flag Football, and he stopped by to show some love at the Goodfellas tailgate!

Come hang with us on game day. 🍕

Columbus, we're joining Crawl With Us and Halloween Bar Crawl on October 31st with some spooky cocktails waiting for you...
10/23/2026

Columbus, we're joining Crawl With Us and Halloween Bar Crawl on October 31st with some spooky cocktails waiting for you! 👻🥃

Stop by Wiseguy Lounge in the Short North from 4–10 PM for Halloween sips and a little spooky fun...ENTER IF YOU DARE! 🎃

10/21/2026

The process vs. the result. 🍕🔥 Hand-tossed dough, authentic NY-style pizza, and slices that don't mess around.

Yams the Word. 🍠✨Dark rum, sweet potato syrup, vanilla, and allspice come together with heavy cream for a rich, velvety ...
10/21/2026

Yams the Word. 🍠✨

Dark rum, sweet potato syrup, vanilla, and allspice come together with heavy cream for a rich, velvety sip full of warm fall flavors. Part of our fall cocktail lineup at Wiseguy Short North.

Goodfellas makes any day better. Mondays included. 🍕🤌
10/19/2026

Goodfellas makes any day better. Mondays included. 🍕🤌

10/18/2026

The family needs to know. What's your go-to slice? 👀

26.2 miles calls for some serious carbs. 🍕🏃Running the The Columbus Marathon this weekend? Whether you're carb loading b...
10/17/2026

26.2 miles calls for some serious carbs. 🍕🏃

Running the The Columbus Marathon this weekend? Whether you're carb loading before or grabbing a celebration slice after, Goodfellas Short North has you covered. Good luck, runners!

10/16/2026

Short North vs. Kirkwood. 🍕🏈

We're backing Ohio State Football this weekend. Think you can handle that, Goodfellas Pizzeria - Kirkwood ? 👀

Who's taking the W?

Fall’s still on the menu. 🍂🥃 Our bartenders have put together a lineup of seasonal cocktails unique to Wiseguy Short Nor...
10/16/2026

Fall’s still on the menu. 🍂🥃 Our bartenders have put together a lineup of seasonal cocktails unique to Wiseguy Short North.

Which one are you ordering next? 👀

We don't skip dessert around here. 🤌🍪 Cannolis, cookies, and cheesecake. Consider it an offer you can't refuse.
10/15/2026

We don't skip dessert around here. 🤌🍪 Cannolis, cookies, and cheesecake. Consider it an offer you can't refuse.

10/15/2026

A proper NY slice. No funny business. 🤌

This is what fresh outta the oven looks like. 🤌
10/13/2026

This is what fresh outta the oven looks like. 🤌

Sausage on pizza? Yes. Paulie’s Favorite? Absolutely. 🍕
10/11/2026

Sausage on pizza? Yes. Paulie’s Favorite? Absolutely. 🍕

Pizza Expo Columbus on the agenda? 🍕 Add Goodfellas Short North to the stop.
10/10/2026

Pizza Expo Columbus on the agenda? 🍕 Add Goodfellas Short North to the stop.

Busy weekend = Goodfellas. 🍕 In the Short North for an OSU weekend? We’ve got the pizza covered.
10/09/2026

Busy weekend = Goodfellas. 🍕 In the Short North for an OSU weekend? We’ve got the pizza covered.

We brought the pizza, they brought the competition. 🍕 A great night with Zeta Phi at Otterbein University supporting Hon...
10/02/2026

We brought the pizza, they brought the competition. 🍕 A great night with Zeta Phi at Otterbein University supporting Honor Flight Columbus.

Address

608 N. High Street
Columbus, OH
43215

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 12am
Tuesday 11am - 12am
Wednesday 11am - 12am
Thursday 11am - 1am
Friday 11am - 3am
Saturday 11am - 3am
Sunday 11am - 12am

Telephone

+16144840277

Website

,

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Goodfellas Pizzeria - Short North posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Goodfellas Pizzeria - Short North:

Shortcuts

Share

Category