What are the opening hours?

Wednesday 5pm - 9pm Thursday 11am - 9pm Friday 11am - 9pm Saturday 11am - 9pm Sunday 11am - 7pm

Fat Arnie’s Sandwich Shop

Home
United States
Columbus, OH
Fat Arnie’s Sandwich Shop

Contact information, map and directions, contact form, opening hours, services, ratings, photos, videos and announcements from Fat Arnie’s Sandwich Shop, Restaurant, 4404 Indianola Avenue, Columbus, OH.
(1)

10/28/2026

Available today at both locations

Sanduche de Carnitas
Pork carnitas, pickled veg and a jalapeño aoli on a potato bun… at both locations today! Fat Arnie’s Sandwich Shop

10/24/2026

Ark Band plays tonight! 8pm! At Rafters!

10/22/2026

Empanada me once, yay for me.
Empanada me twice, I’m ignoring all my responsibilities.
Empanada me three times, I’m in empanada heaven. 😇🥟

10/21/2026

🚨New Menu Item🚨
El Chancho
Cured and roasted pork belly, coconut spiced vinaigrette slaw, house sauce on a toasted hoagie

10/20/2026

🚨 FAT ARNIE’S TURNS ONE TODAY! 🚨

One year down, and we’re just getting started. ❤️💚 We wouldn’t be here without all of you showing up, spreading the word, and letting us feed you.

🎉 COME CELEBRATE WITH US ALL WEEK LONG! 🎉

And if you need another reason to stop by, Rafters is having live music this Saturday! 👇

🎸 LIVE MUSIC WITH THE ARK BAND
📅 Saturday, October 24
⏰ 8 PM
📍 Rafters B**r Pub
4404 Indianola Ave, Columbus, OH 43214

Grab a sandwich, grab an empanada, grab a b**r, and help us celebrate one whole year of Fat Arnie’s. 🍻

YEAR ONE: IN THE BOOKS. YEAR TWO: LET’S GET WEIRD. 🤘

10/18/2026

Nietzsche asked us to become who we are. She became hungry.
Oh yea, and it’s this ones birthday👇🏽Happy birthday!

10/17/2026

You’re not even my type… and yet here I am, risking it all

10/16/2026

To exist is to suffer. To suffer with an empty stomach is unnecessary.

10/15/2026

Your Nonna called. She said you’re not eating enough. 🇮🇹🤌

Try the Italian Pork Porchetta.

10/15/2026

Whose idea was it to change the game to 1pm?
Rafters will have the game on Thursday 1pm and Friday 6pm!
Eat Fat Arnie's, Drinking Rafters 🤙🏽⚾️

Address

4404 Indianola Avenue
Columbus, OH
43214

Opening Hours

Wednesday	5pm - 9pm
Thursday	11am - 9pm
Friday	11am - 9pm
Saturday	11am - 9pm
Sunday	11am - 7pm

Website

http://fatarnies.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Fat Arnie’s Sandwich Shop posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.