The Rutherford Cafe

02/14/2026

Happy Valentine's Day 💘

The Rutherford Cafe will be CLOSED today due to staffing. We apologize for the inconvenience, and hope to see you tomorrow!

01/25/2026

Snowmageddon 2026 Update: Due to the declaration of a Level 3 Snow Emergency, The Rutherford Cafe will remain CLOSED on Monday 1/26 for the safety of our staff and customers.
Stay safe, stay warm, and we'll (hopefully) see you all on Tuesday!

01/25/2026

The Rutherford Cafe will be CLOSED on Sunday, 1/25 due to the incoming weather for the safety of our staff and customers. Stay safe and warm, and we hope to see you Monday!

12/21/2025

Happy Holidays from all of us at The Rutherford Cafe! We have some special hours coming up in the near future:
We'll be closed on Christmas Eve AND Christmas Day (12/24 &12/25)
We'll also be closed on New Year's Eve (12/31) and from January 1st thru the 8th to take a little break.
Come get your Rutherford fix on the other days before we're closed for a whole week!

11/29/2025

We will be CLOSED Sunday, 11/30 due to a staffing issue. We apologize for any inconvenience and hope to see you Monday!

10/20/2025

Not the update we wanted: Spectrum is also experiencing an outage, so now our phone service is down as well. We're still here, though, so come on into 9 E. William Street for a delicious breakfast or lunch sandwich!

10/20/2025

Ah, Monday is Mondaying...
Our point-of-sale system, like many systems this morning, is experiencing some technical difficulties. What will affect you, the customer:

-Our online ordering is down, which means our delivery is currently unavailable :(
-We can still take your order over the phone for pickup: Give us a call at 740-990-0085

We apologize for any inconvenience this causes, and we'll update you as soon as we're back up to full functionality!

10/09/2025

Great news! We're back in business - order now at therutherfordcafe.com or stop in to see us before 3pm!

A cozy counter-service sandwich shop serving gourmet yet uncomplicated sandwiches made with fresh, high-quality ingredients.

10/08/2025

Welp. We've got a bit of a plumbing situation at The Rutherford Cafe 😬 Unfortunately, that means we have to stay closed in the morning until we can get it resolved - we're hoping that we can be back up and running by lunchtime, but we'll keep you posted. 🤞

10/01/2025

It's baaaaaaaaaaack: The Grateful Gobble is back for the season! Hearty Multigrain Bread, fresh Turkey, Cranberry Compote, Garlic Mayo, creamy Gouda cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, and Carrots - It's like Thanksgiving Dinner on a sandwich! If you haven't tried this one yet, you absolutely should 😋

09/30/2025

It's time for a menu update!

New this fall: the Roast Beast Feast! Cranberry compote, Horseradish sauce, creamy Gouda Cheese, Lettuce, Onion, and tender Roast Beef on a soft Baguette 😋 Yum! Come try it out today!

08/29/2025

The Rutherford Cafe will be CLOSED on Monday, 9/1 for Labor Day. Come see us this weekend so you don't miss us too much! 😉

Thank you to our employees for all of your excellent work!