11/02/2026
Stop right here if you still want to take a crack at the mystery flavor! I’ll have scoops (with scratch off labels) in the freezers later this week. Dozens of guesses in the mystery cauldron this year and nobody got it quite right! I know it drove you insane to leave without knowing what it really was, so here is your reveal: this year’s flavor was roasted carrot & cardamom! Heavily inspired by carrot halwa, and a lot harder to detect when you can’t see the flavor’s originally vibrant orange hue. I’ll reach out to the winner of our gift card tomorrow, but in the meantime— I’ll leave you with some highlights from your guesses. Lots of fruit loops, miso, rosemary, and blueberry. Chicken. Matcha. Hot dog. Spinach. Caramelized onion. This challenge proves time and time again that we taste with our eyes almost as much as we taste with our tongues. Thanks for playing along!
