Moonlight Creamery

Home
United States
Fairport, NY
Moonlight Creamery

Call Directions Website

Welcome to Moonlight Creamery in Fairport, NY! Welcome to Moonlight Creamery in Fairport, NY. We make all of our own premium ice cream right on the premises.
(480)

We also offer fair trade organic coffee, artisan chocolate, pastries, w**e, b**r and a light lunch menu. Stop in and Eat Dessert First!

10/29/2026

ATTENTION, ICE CREAM LOVERS!!

Our chef just made something EXTRA special, and if you love marshmallows, you do NOT want to miss this one!

TOASTED MARSHMALLOW ICE CREAM IS HERE!

This flavor is a marshmallow lover’s dream! Our chef hand-toasts marshmallows until they’re crispy, giving this delicious ice cream those incredible smoky, toasted marshmallow pieces you can actually TASTE in every bite! Trust us, this one is something special!

We usually bring this fan favorite out sometime between now and Christmas, but we decided not to make you wait any longer!

HERE’S THE CATCH, MOONLIGHTERS… WE ONLY MADE ONE BATCH! That’s right, just TWO TUBS!

So if toasted marshmallows and homemade ice cream sound like your kind of heaven, get down to Moonlight Creamery and grab a scoop before it’s gone!

TWO TUBS. ONE AMAZING FLAVOR. WHEN IT’S GONE, IT’S GONE!

See you at Moonlight!

10/25/2026

ATTENTION, MOONLIGHT CUSTOMERS! THANKSGIVING FLAVORS HAVE ARRIVED AT MOONLIGHT CREAMERY!

Who says you have to wait until Thanksgiving dinner to enjoy some of your favorite holiday flavors? We’re bringing a little Thanksgiving magic to our ice cream case, and you’re not going to want to miss these!

Here’s what’s waiting for you:

Cranberry Sorbet — Made with fresh cranberries, this festive favorite brings a bright, tangy burst of holiday flavor to every scoop!

Sweet Potato with Toasted Marshmallows — All the cozy goodness of a Thanksgiving classic, featuring sweet potato ice cream with real toasted marshmallows. It’s like your holiday dinner favorite met your favorite dessert!

Sweet Corn Ice Cream — This is one of our November favorites.! We’ve had so many requests lately for this ice cream that we had to bring it out a week early. If you haven’t tried it yet, now’s your chance!

These Thanksgiving flavors are here for a limited time! We make our ice cream in small batches, so once they’re gone, they’re gone!

Come on down to Moonlight Creamery in Fairport and get your scoop of Thanksgiving before it’s too late!

09/20/2026

🍂🍎🎃 HELLO, MOONLIGHT CUSTOMERS… FALL IS FINALLY HERE! 🎃🍎🍂

Can you feel it?! The leaves are getting ready to show off those beautiful fall colors, there’s a crisp breeze in the air, and the humidity has FINALLY dropped! 🙌🍁

We LOVE fall here at Moonlight Creamery, and we’re celebrating with some seriously delicious flavors! 🍦❤️

🎃 Our Pumpkin Ice Cream is officially OUT!

🍎 And TODAY, we’re bringing back our HOMEMADE APPLE PIE ICE CREAM! 🥧🍦

And we’ve got TWO versions for you:
🍎 Classic Apple Pie
🍎 Gluten-Free & Dairy-Free Apple Pie

But wait… IT GETS EVEN BETTER! 🤩

For the rest of this week, THROUGH SATURDAY, SEPTEMBER 26TH, we’ll also be serving up our DONUT SUNDAES! 🍩🍦

That means you can take that delicious Apple Pie Ice Cream and put it BETWEEN TWO SLICES OF DONUT! 😍🥧🍩

Honestly… if that doesn’t scream FALL, we don’t know what does!

So grab your family, grab your friends, grab your appetite and come celebrate fall with us at Moonlight Creamery! 🍂❤️

And remember… we make everything in small batches, so these fall favorites are available WHILE SUPPLIES LAST!

🍎🎃🍦 COME GET YOUR FALL ON AT MOONLIGHT! 🍦🎃🍎

09/13/2026

🎃🍂 IT’S THAT TIME AGAIN, MOONLIGHTERS! 🍂🎃

You know what that means… the weather is starting to change, the leaves will soon be showing off those beautiful oranges and reds, and the PUMPKIN PEOPLE HAVE ARRIVED! 😂🎃

We’re bringing back one of our fall favorites — GREAT PUMPKIN PIE! 🥧🎃 And for our gluten-free & dairy-free friends, we’ve got you covered with our GF/DF Pumpkin Pie made with almond milk! 🙌

Remember, we make everything in small batches, so don’t wait too long to get your pumpkin fix! Come on down and make sure you get your Pumpkin before it disappears! 🎃🍦

Not a pumpkin person? Don’t worry — we haven’t forgotten about you! 😉 Over the coming weeks, we’ll be bringing out even MORE fall favorites, including:

🍎 Apple Pie
🌽 Sweet Corn
🍠 Sweet Potato Toasted with Marshmallows 🤤

But for now… LET THE PUMPKIN PEOPLE ENJOY! 🎃😂

Come celebrate the start of fall with a scoop! 🍦🍂
While supplies last!

08/11/2026

🎉🍰 PARTY CAKE IS BACK!!! 🍰🎉

Cue the confetti… because Party Cake is officially back in the case! 🎊🥳

This delicious treat is a NON-DAIRY & GLUTEN-FREE cake batter ice cream loaded with colorful sprinkles! 🌈🍦 Basically, it’s a party in every scoop! 🎂✨

So come on down and GET YOUR SCOOP ON! 🙌

And remember, we make everything in small batches, so this party won’t last forever! ⏰🍨

Available while supplies last! 🎉

07/26/2026

🎄☀️ CHRISTMAS IN JULY HAS ARRIVED! ☀️🎄

🚨 Attention, Frozen Cocoa fans! 🚨

We just made TWO tubs of our famous Frozen Cocoa! If you’ve been waiting for it to return, this is your moment. Consider this your Christmas in July! 🎁🍫

But wait… there’s more!

🍌 Our Golden Banana is back in the case too! This fan-favorite is non-dairy, gluten-free, and made with real bananas for an unbelievably creamy, delicious treat that everyone can enjoy.

As always, everything is made in small batches, so when it’s gone… it’s gone!

Who’s stopping by for Frozen Cocoa? 🙋‍♂️🍫 Or are you grabbing a scoop of Golden Banana? 🍌

07/23/2026

If today had a résumé… it would be pretty impressive. ☀️🍦🎶

Qualifications include:
✅ Perfect sunny summer weather
✅ A beautiful evening ahead
✅ Live music tonight in the gazebo for the Thursday Night Concert Series
✅ And the return of a flavor everyone has been waiting for…

That’s right… our Bicentennial Berry ice cream is FINALLY back in the case! 🍓🎉

We know so many of you have been patiently waiting, and today is the day. This small-batch favorite has returned and is ready to make your day even sweeter.

But wait… every celebration needs a little something extra, so we also brought back our Raspberry Riesling Sorbet! 🍇✨

So if sunshine, music, and amazing ice cream sound like your kind of evening, we know exactly where you should be.

Come enjoy a scoop, take a walk through Fairport, and soak up this beautiful summer night with us.

Remember… everything we make is in small batches, so don’t wait too long! 🍦❤️

06/30/2026

🚨 Calling all Moonlight Creamery customers… we need your help! 🚨

🔎 Where’s Waldo? Starting July 1, Waldo will be hiding in 27 local Fairport businesses—including Moonlight Creamery!

Here’s how to join the fun:
📍 Visit participating businesses and spot Waldo.
✅ Collect a store stamp or signature at each location.
🎉 Once you’ve collected at least 10 stamps or signatures, head over to Another Chapter Bookstore to claim a Waldo poster and a $1 off coupon (available to the first 125 Waldo spotters).

Think you can find them all? If you collect all 27 stamps or signatures, you’ll also be entered into a grand prize drawing for a special Waldo prize!

🗓️ The search runs July 1 through July 31, with the prize drawing taking place at 6:00 PM on August 4 at Another Chapter Bookstore.

We’re so excited that Another Chapter Bookstore is hosting this amazing community event and bringing people together to support our wonderful small businesses throughout Fairport. We can’t wait to see all of you on the hunt!

👀 Keep your eyes peeled… Waldo is waiting!

06/27/2026

📸 Picture this…

It’s a Friday night. We boldly take Cookies & Cream out of the case… and replace it with our OH SO GOOD Pistachio Ice Cream! 💚🍦

Now comes the real question…

Will there be anything left of this small batch by the end of the night? 🤔

Honestly… we have no idea. 😂

If you’ve been waiting for our rich, creamy, nutty pistachio ice cream, tonight is your chance. But remember—we make everything in small batches, and Friday nights have a funny way of making ice cream disappear.

Come help us solve the mystery… or be part of the reason it’s gone! 😉

06/24/2026

🎉 Attention our gluten-free, dairy-free friends! 🎉

We just put our Party Cake Ice Cream back in the case! 🎂🍦

This fan-favorite is gluten-free, dairy-free, and packed with all the birthday cake flavor you could ask for. As always, we make everything in small batches, and this time we only have two tubs available!

With it being the last day of school, we’re expecting a busy day, so if you’ve been waiting for Party Cake to return, now is the time to come grab a scoop before it’s gone.

We’ll see you at Moonlight Creamery! 🌙✨

Address

36 West Avenue, Ste 2
Fairport, NY
14450

Telephone

+15852230880

Website

http://www.moonlightcreamery.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Moonlight Creamery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.