What are the opening hours?

Monday 2pm - 9:30pm Tuesday 2pm - 9:30pm Wednesday 2pm - 9:30pm Thursday 2pm - 9:30pm Friday 11:30am - 10pm Saturday 11am - 10pm Sunday 11:30am - 9:30pm

Moonlight Creamery

Home
United States
Fairport, NY
Moonlight Creamery

Welcome to Moonlight Creamery in Fairport, NY! Welcome to Moonlight Creamery in Fairport, NY. We make all of our own premium ice cream right on the premises.
(480)

We also offer fair trade organic coffee, artisan chocolate, pastries, wine, beer and a light lunch menu. Stop in and Eat Dessert First!

06/21/2026

🎉 Happy Father’s Day to all the amazing dads out there! 🎉

Whether you’re spending the day grilling, relaxing, fishing, or chasing the kids around, we hope your day is filled with family, laughter, and of course… ice cream! 🍦

For our gluten-free and dairy-free friends, we currently have TWO fan favorites in the case:
🍪 Mocha Cookie
🍪 Cookies & Cream

But that’s not all…

⏰ At 5:00 PM TONIGHT, we’re releasing a VERY LIMITED batch of our Gluten-Free & Dairy-Free Key Lime Pie Ice Cream! 🍋🥧

Made with gluten-free, dairy-free graham cracker pieces and packed with bright, tangy key lime flavor, this one is absolutely incredible. Our chef knocked it out of the park!

And to help celebrate Father’s Day, we’ll also be dropping our customer-favorite:
🥃🍒 Bourbon Sour Cherry Ice Cream at 5:00 PM!

As always, these flavors are made in small batches, and when we say limited, we mean LIMITED. We only made TWO tubs of the Gluten-Free & Dairy-Free Key Lime Pie, so don’t wait too long!

See you tonight at Moonlight Creamery! 🌙🍦

06/09/2026

🐾🍦 BIG NEWS, MOONLIGHTERS! 🍦🐾

We are thrilled to announce that Moonlight Creamery is teaming up with GRASP Animal Rescue for an Ice Cream Social & Dog Adoption Event!

Join us on Saturday, June 13th at 4:00 PM for an afternoon filled with delicious homemade ice cream, wagging tails, and plenty of puppy love. We’ll have some adorable furry friends right out front in the park looking for their forever homes!

Whether you’re hoping to adopt, thinking about fostering, or simply want to spend some time with some very good dogs, this is the perfect opportunity to support a wonderful local rescue while enjoying your favorite frozen treat.

Bring your family, bring your friends, and bring your love for animals! Who knows… you might leave with a scoop of ice cream and a chance meeting with a new best friend. ❤️🐶

📍 Moonlight Creamery
📅 June 13th
⏰ 4:00 PM

We can’t wait to see you there!

05/30/2026

🌽 Attention Corn Lovers! 🌽

We know… this might be one of the most unexpected flavors to show up in the case right now, but when has Moonlight ever been afraid to keep things interesting?

We just dropped a small batch of our Sweet Corn Ice Cream into the case! Made in-house in small batches, it’s rich, creamy, slightly sweet, and packed with that fresh sweet corn flavor that somehow turns into pure ice cream magic.

If you’ve had it before, you already know why people wait for it. If you’ve never tried it, this is your chance to discover one of our most unique and surprisingly delicious flavors.

But fair warning: it’s a small batch, and once it’s gone, it’s gone.

So for all you corn enthusiasts, curious food adventurers, and anyone who loves trying something a little different, come grab a scoop before it disappears! 🌽🍦

05/23/2026

What a rainy day, Moonlight fans! 🌧️🍦

Since the weather decided to slow things down a little today, we decided to brighten it up the best way we know how… by throwing our homemade Key Lime Pie ice cream into the case! 💚🥧 Our chef just whipped up a small batch, and honestly, a cozy rainy day feels like the PERFECT excuse for ice cream.

And that’s not all…

🎂 Party Cake is back in the case too! Our gluten-free, dairy-free cake ice cream is so ridiculously good, we think it might even beat the version with dairy and gluten. Yep… we said it.

☕🍪 We also have our Mocha Cookie — a rich chocolate coffee ice cream loaded with crushed Oreo cookies. Oh, and surprise… it’s ALSO non-dairy and gluten-free, but you’d never know from the taste.

Remember, everything here is made in small batches, so once these flavors disappear, they’re gone! So grab your raincoat, splash through a few puddles, and sled on down to Moonlight Creamery for the perfect rainy-day treat. 🌧️✨

05/13/2026

🎉 Hey Moonlighters! 🎉

Who says you need a birthday, celebration, or special occasion to PARTY?! Around here, if there’s cake ice cream involved… that’s reason enough. 🍰🍦

Today we loaded up the ice cream case with our famous Piece of Cake Ice Cream AND for all our dairy-free friends, we also brought out a Non-Dairy Gluten-Free Party Cake Ice Cream! 🎂✨

So go ahead… dig deep down inside and find that inner 6-year-old who still gets excited about sprinkles, cake, and ice cream for absolutely no reason at all. 🥳

Come celebrate absolutely nothing with us and grab a scoop (or two) before the party melts away! 🎈🍨

05/12/2026

Good morning Moonlighters! 🌞🍦

We know this post might be a little early… but honestly, who says ice cream can’t be breakfast? 😄

Today is all about one of the all-time favorites… COOKIES & CREAM! We just brought out our rich, creamy homemade Cookies & Cream ice cream made with our Tahitian vanilla base, the perfect touch of sweetness, and absolutely loaded with cookies. 🍪✨

BUT WAIT… we didn’t stop there!

Alongside the original, we also dropped our Gluten-Free Dairy-Free Cookies & Cream into the case today! Our chef worked incredibly hard to make this version taste almost identical to the original, and we are so excited for our gluten-free and dairy-free friends!.💙

And if you’ve ever been into the shop, you already know… our waffle cones are made fresh in-house and the smell alone is enough to make you hungry the second you walk through the door. 🤤 Fresh waffle cones + Cookies & Cream = a dangerous combination.

For our gluten-free and dairy-free customers, we’ve got you covered too! We carry gluten-free cake cones AND gluten-free sugar cones so nobody has to miss out on the fun. 🙌

Come down and see us sometime today! Remember, we make everything in small batches, and around here flavors can disappear FAST! 🍦⏳

05/11/2026

🌶🍫 ATTENTION MOONLIGHTERS! 🍫🌶

We’ve had SO many people asking about our Spicy Chocolate Ice Cream this week… wondering when it would finally return…

WELL THE WAIT IS OVER. 🚨

As I’m posting this right now, we literally just dropped it back into the case! 🔥🍨

This unbelievably rich chocolate ice cream is blended with chili, cayenne pepper, and just a touch of cinnamon to create that perfect sweet heat combo that keeps everyone coming back for more. Smooth, creamy, chocolatey… and then BAM… a little kick at the end. 😍🔥

If you’ve never tried it before, this is your sign.
If you’ve been asking for it… THIS IS YOUR MOMENT. 👀

Now remember — we make everything in small batches, and I only have TWO tubs available right now. So if it disappears by tomorrow, don’t panic… we’ll make it again soon. But if you want to guarantee yourself a scoop, today might be the day to make the trip. 🌙🍨

05/09/2026

Happy Mother’s Day weekend to all the incredible moms, grandmas, stepmoms, dog moms, and mother figures out there! I am dedicating this post to my two mothers Rebecca, and my Godmother 🍰Kate. As well as a shout out to Heidi 🌙 one of the founders of Moonlight Creamery. While being a great mother to two kids was able to start our delicious ice cream adventure. 💐 Today we celebrate the love, strength, kindness, and endless care that mothers bring into our lives every single day. Thank you for the hugs, the guidance, the sacrifices, and the unconditional love that makes the world brighter. ❤️

To honor motherhood this weekend, we created two very special small-batch flavors inspired by a beautiful bouquet of flowers for Mom 🌸

Blackberry Rose — a rich and elegant flavor bursting with bold rose notes and delicate blackberry sweetness.
Honey Lavender — smooth, calming, and lightly floral with a touch of honey sweetness

These flavors are our sweet little tribute to the mothers we love so much. But remember… we make everything in small batches, and Mother’s Day weekend gets busy fast! So come down and grab a scoop (or a few pints 😉) for your mom before these special flavors disappear.

Celebrate Mom with flowers you can eat this year 💐🍦

05/06/2026

🚨🍦 ATTENTION MOONLIGHT FANS!! 🍦🚨

Today is a flavor-packed kind of day and you do NOT want to miss this lineup…

✨ Pistachio is BACK in the case
✨ Golden Banana has returned (and rumor has it… it’s NEXT LEVEL with some Hershey syrup on top 👀🍌🍫)

Now if you ask me… I’m going full combo mode — Peanut Butter Cookie Dough + Banana with a drizzle of our homemade peanut butter sauce 🤤🔥

But hey, there are no wrong choices here… mix it, match it, go wild — just make sure you get here before these tubs disappear!!

💛 Also, a HUGE shoutout to the amazing staff over at Northside School! I had the pleasure of being part of your staff appreciation today and wow… what an incredible, welcoming group. You guys definitely know how to enjoy some ice cream!!

And it was awesome getting to see some of my local kids in their natural habitat 😂🙌

Special shoutout to Joey — thanks for coming over and saying hi!

Come see us soon, Moonlight crew… these flavors won’t last long!! 🍦✨

Address

36 West Avenue, Ste 2
Fairport, NY
14450

Opening Hours

Monday	2pm - 9:30pm
Tuesday	2pm - 9:30pm
Wednesday	2pm - 9:30pm
Thursday	2pm - 9:30pm
Friday	11:30am - 10pm
Saturday	11am - 10pm
Sunday	11:30am - 9:30pm

Telephone

+15852230880

Website

http://www.moonlightcreamery.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Moonlight Creamery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Address
Telephone
Opening Hours
Alerts
Contact The Business
Claim ownership or report listing

Want your business to be the top-listed Restaurant in Fairport?