Terry's Toffee

Terry's Toffee Gourmet toffee, gelato, confections, and coffee downtown Highland and online at terrystoffee.com Hand-crafted. Family-owned. Elevated ingredients.

Following a recipe passed down from Terry’s Grandmother McCall, we make artisanal toffee with the best ingredients we can source from our partners around the world. We have expanded on the family recipe to include inventive toffee flavors, as well as pairings with biscotti, ice cream and popcorn. From our family-owned brick and mortar shop in Chicago, we are committed to making every batch by hand, with all-natural ingredients and no additives. We hope you enjoy.

We don't usually compare toffee to wine. This one earned it. 🍷✨Toasted Sesame Toffee is here β€” our classic family recipe...
06/25/2026

We don't usually compare toffee to wine. This one earned it. 🍷✨
Toasted Sesame Toffee is here β€” our classic family recipe, dipped in milk chocolate, finished with toasted sesame. Toasty up front, sweet in the middle, and a savory note at the end that lingers just long enough to make you go back for another piece.
It's nuanced. It's a little unexpected. It's a limited run β€” once it's gone, it's gone.

Come taste what we mean.

πŸ“ 1853 2nd St, Highland Park, IL

πŸ›οΈ TerrysToffee.com



toasted sesame toffee | new toffee flavor highland park | milk chocolate toffee | limited edition toffee north shore

Hot girl summer? More like cold drink summer. β˜€οΈπŸ‹We've got lemonades that taste like a vacation in a cup β€” and we are NO...
06/25/2026

Hot girl summer? More like cold drink summer. β˜€οΈπŸ‹

We've got lemonades that taste like a vacation in a cup β€” and we are NOT being dramatic.

β†’ πŸ“ Strawberry Rose β€” fancy and fruity and absolutely worth it
β†’ 🌿 Frosted Mint β€” cool, crisp, and basically a vibe
β†’ πŸ’œ Lavender β€” yes, it's as dreamy as it sounds

Swipe through and pick your flavor. Then come get one before summer slips away.

πŸ“ 1853 2nd St, Highland Park, IL
πŸ›οΈ TerrysToffee.com



lemonade highland park | summer drinks north shore | lavender lemonade | strawberry rose lemonade | refreshing summer drinks chicago

Happy Pride Month! 🌈Same classic recipe you love, dressed up with a little pride flourish β€” finished with a "Pride" mess...
06/22/2026

Happy Pride Month! 🌈
Same classic recipe you love, dressed up with a little pride flourish β€” finished with a "Pride" message on top, because the toffee should match the energy.

Stop in, grab a piece, and celebrate with us. Everyone's welcome at Terry's β€” all month, every month.

πŸ“ 1853 2nd St, Highland Park, IL

πŸ›οΈ TerrysToffee.com



pride toffee highland park | pride month treats north shore | rainbow toffee chicago

06/22/2026

having a bad day?
rough week?
everything just a lot right now?
here's your reminder πŸ‘‡
toffee makes everything better.
scientifically proven. (okay, we made that up. but also… come in and tell us we're wrong.)

πŸ“ 1853 2nd St, Highland Park, IL
πŸ›οΈ TerrysToffee.com



toffee highland park | handcrafted toffee north shore | best toffee chicago | treat yourself dessert | terry's toffee il

Treat dad to something super sweetβ€” Father's Day is this weekend!🎁 Classic toffee topped with a Father's Day messagesπŸ’° $...
06/19/2026

Treat dad to something super sweetβ€” Father's Day is this weekend!

🎁 Classic toffee topped with a Father's Day messages

πŸ’° $5 off any order of $50+, in-store β€” just stop in before you celebrate dad.

πŸ“ 1853 2nd St, Highland Park, IL

πŸ›οΈ TerrysToffee.com



last minute father's day gift highland park | father's day toffee north shore | gifts for dad chicago

06/17/2026

Okay real talk β€” the name might throw you off. 🍯

No honey. Zero honey. Not a drop.

So what IS Honeycomb Toffee? It's our original toffee recipe with a little bit of magic that gives it this light, airy, impossibly crisp texture that basically shatters in the best way possible. Think: gourmet candy bar energy, but make it handcrafted in Highland Park.

Then you pick your chocolate:
🀎 Milk β€” classic, creamy, can't go wrong
πŸ–€ Dark β€” a little fancy, a little dangerous
🀍 White β€” sweet, smooth, and somehow underrated

This is a limited run β€” meaning you should probably stop what you're doing and come get some. Unless you want it on our permanent menu? πŸ‘€ Tell us in the comments and we just might make it happen.

Because around here, if toffee lovers want it β€” toffee lovers get it. 🍫

πŸ“ 1853 2nd St, Highland Park, IL
πŸ›οΈ TerrysToffee.com


honeycomb toffee highland park | new toffee flavor | handcrafted toffee north shore | best toffee chicago | limited edition sweets chicago

05/30/2026
05/27/2026
05/25/2026

IT'S OVER 70 DEGREES AND WE ARE NOT WASTING IT. πŸ™Œβ˜€οΈ

Coats off. Windows down. Kids in the car. We are going to Terry's and I don't want to hear a single word about homework.
Gelato sundaes. NOW. Let's go. 🍨

πŸ“ 1853 2nd St, Highland Park, IL
πŸ›οΈ TerrysToffee.com



chicago spring | gelato near me | highland park il | north shore moms | family treats chicago | best gelato | finally warm chicago

05/23/2026

We love tacos as much as the next person… but have you MET Gelato Nachos? πŸ¨πŸ§‡

3 scoops of your favorite gelato served with waffle chips, and we are never going back to regular dessert again. Ever.

Maybe this is the perfect treat on Taco Tuesday. 😏

Come in and build your scoop.

πŸ“ 1853 2nd St, Highland Park, IL
πŸ›οΈ TerrysToffee.com



gelato nachos | best gelato highland park | unique desserts chicago | north shore foodie | gelato near me | dessert goals | highland park il

Some things in life are just an automatic YES. πŸ™‹β€β™€οΈβœ¨No thinking. No hesitation. Just yes.Swipe through and try to say no...
05/22/2026

Some things in life are just an automatic YES. πŸ™‹β€β™€οΈβœ¨

No thinking. No hesitation. Just yes.

Swipe through and try to say no. We dare you. 😏

Every flavor. Every time. Yes, yes, and yes.

πŸ›οΈ Order yours at TerrysToffee.com



artisan toffee | small batch candy | handcrafted toffee | best toffee | foodie gifts | toffee flavors | candy gifts

Address

1853 2nd Street
Highland Park, IL
60035

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 8pm
Tuesday 11am - 8pm
Wednesday 11am - 8pm
Thursday 11am - 8pm
Friday 11am - 9:30pm
Saturday 10:30am - 9:30pm
Sunday 10:30am - 6pm

Telephone

+13127332700

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Terry's Toffee posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Share