The Meatball Mafia

The Meatball Mafia A couple of Italian brothers from YTOWN bringing Youngstown inspired Italian eats from our location in Old Hilliard (Center Street Market)
(1)

Youngstown Italian eats in the 614!

Hello Mafiosos! Look at this beaut🤌 ā›±ļøIt’s a beautiful day, the pies are slingin, and the meatballs are calling your nam...
05/03/2026

Hello Mafiosos! Look at this beaut🤌
ā›±ļøIt’s a beautiful day, the pies are slingin, and the meatballs are calling your name!
We’ll see you today from 11am-7pm
Summer hours start Sunday 5/10 when we get all our college kids back. We can’t wait to get the gang back together so we can fulfill those Mafia cravings

Want to preorder for pickup?
šŸ“²Text 614-564-7251
šŸš—Delivery available at www.themeatballmafia.com

Hello mafiosos! Just wanted to give an update on why we close at 7 on some days and 8 on the others. Currently we have 6...
05/03/2026

Hello mafiosos! Just wanted to give an update on why we close at 7 on some days and 8 on the others. Currently we have 6 people (who all live in Hilliard) working for a 7 day operation. I’m trying not to overwork them too much. We’re waiting on our college kids to come back as we haven’t had any high school applicants this season (first time since 2021).
Please. Do not give us bad reviews because we closed at the stated time. These reviews last a lifetime.
The kids will be trickling back in the next few weeks and we’ll extend the hours to 8 and 9.
And if you know Heather Lindsay, kindly ask her to delete this review.

04/17/2026
04/17/2026

Hello Mafiosos. The post I’m about to make brings me great embarrassment as a resident of Hilliard. Recently my staff has experienced abusive behavior from minors ordering from us. Everything from chanting ā€œNO TIP!ā€ to saying directly disgusting things to my staff. Heading into the summer months I want to make it perfectly clear this will NOT be tolerated, and we reserve the right to refuse service to ANYONE we deem to be a prick. Have a conversation with your children about what public behavior is, and what common decency is as well.
Enjoy the weather. Enjoy the pizza.
-Robert

I was typing an April fools post where I misled you all into believing we were calling it quits and going back to the fo...
04/01/2026

I was typing an April fools post where I misled you all into believing we were calling it quits and going back to the food truck life. While writing the post it gave me horrendous flashbacks of sweating my meatballs off all summer, and being poor all winter. I couldn’t even joke about it.
Anyhow, happy April fools day. We’ll be extending hours soon!
Parents of Hilliard: if you have a high schooler over the age of 16 who wants a job, we need a couple mafiosos for the summer! Perks of the job are obviously pizza, and they get to say for the rest of their lives their first job was with the Mafia🤌

Yes. This picture is how the meatball mafia started in 2013. You can’t see it, but there’s a bullet hole in the window

To all my fellow 330 transplants, happy 330 Day!
03/30/2026

To all my fellow 330 transplants, happy 330 Day!

You know what it is 🤌Today and tomorrow are your last chances to get a Cincinnati 6 until the fall!
03/28/2026

You know what it is 🤌Today and tomorrow are your last chances to get a Cincinnati 6 until the fall!

03/28/2026

Available through Sunday!

Hello Mafiosos! It’s opening day for the Reds at 4:10! āš¾ļø Don’t miss out on our most controversial specialty pizza, the ...
03/26/2026

Hello Mafiosos! It’s opening day for the Reds at 4:10! āš¾ļø Don’t miss out on our most controversial specialty pizza, the Cincinnati 6, available for a limited time🤌
Today through Sunday at the Center Street Market location only!
-Skyline Chili
-Cheddar Cheese
-Hot Dogs
-Onions
-Mustard
-Oyster Crackers

Want to preorder? Text 614-564-7251 with your name, order, and preferred pickup time!
It’s the yellow mustard that does it for me😘

Hello Mafiosos! It’s  ! And we’re back to being open on Mondays, so come out an get that meatball fix handledšŸ¤ŒšŸ“ø by thats...
03/09/2026

Hello Mafiosos! It’s ! And we’re back to being open on Mondays, so come out an get that meatball fix handled🤌

šŸ“ø by thatsandwichdude

Address

5354 Center Street
Hilliard, OH
43026

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 7pm
Tuesday 11am - 8pm
Wednesday 11am - 8pm
Thursday 11am - 8pm
Friday 11am - 9pm
Saturday 11am - 9pm
Sunday 11am - 7pm

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Meatball Mafia posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Share