11/03/2026
Don't miss your chance to have Mighty Fine pie (and pot pies, quiches and biscuits) on your table this year. Your taste buds and guests will agree that MF is creating some of Long Island's best pies.... all baked from scratch using our buttery crust. Yum!
Pre-orders accepted until Nov 21 at 5 pm or sell out. Pick up in Huntington Mon-Weds Nov 23-25 8:30 am to 7 pm, and on Thanksgiving Day between 8:30 am and 11:30 am.
Or pick up at our South Shore partners on Weds Nov 25 2-6 pm: Great South Bay Brewery, 25 Drexel Ave, Bay Shore.
Visit our website to order and select your pickup time.