Fish Tales Market and Eatery

Fish Tales Market and Eatery Welcome to Fish Tales Market and Eatery in Marathon, a “local’s favorite” where you will find fresh Seafood, Fish & Steaks, plus homecooked meals.

Fish Tales is the oldest Fish Market & Restaurant in Marathon. Locally, family & veteran owned. take out and curbside pickup available

07/24/2026

FISH TALES DINNER SPECIALS FOR FRIDAY🎉 COME SEE US FOR DINNER OR CALL IN YOUR TO GO ORDER😎

FRESH-MADE TO ORDER: Regular/Decaf Coffee & Espresso
FRESH SQUEEZED LIME-ADE

1/2 # STEAMED PEELED SHRIMP $13.95 OR
WHOLE POUND STEAMED PEELED SHRIMP $25.95

HOMEMADE FISH SPREAD $14.95
FRESH FRIED GREEN TOMOATOES W/ SIDE JOHNNY DRESSING $12.95
FRIED WISCONSIN CHEESECURDS W/ SIRRACHA MAYO $12.95

NEW: SURFSIDE VODKA ICED TEA- ISLAMORADA CITRUS ALE – TORPEDO IPA -COCONUT KEY LIME ALE -IPA VOODOO RANGER JUICY HAZE - SWEET WATER HAZY IPA NUTRL VODKA SELTZER WATERMELON - NUTRL VODKA SELTZER PINEAPPLE
FAMOSA BEER FROM GUATEMALA

HOMEMADE SOUP & CHOWDERS:
RED CONCH CHOWDER N.E. CLAM CHOWDER
CRAWDAD CHOWDER BEEF & BEAN CHILI

SIDE CHOICES:
COLESLAW FRENCH FRIES NEW POTATOES POTATO SALAD
GREEN BEANS APPLE SAUCE BLACK BEANS & RICE

DINNER SPECIALS
OUR SMOKED PORK CHOP W/ MASHED POTATOES/GRAVY & GREEN BEANS… $21.95

THE WEINER SAMPLER – All Beef Dog, Brat & Italian Sausage WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $17.95

HOMEMADE SMOKED SALMON MELT ON WHITE OR RYE W/ CUP OF SOUP $16.95

JOHNNY SALAD OR CAESAR SALAD TOPPED WITH SMOKED SALMON SALAD $18.95

HAM STEAK WITH MASHED POTATO/GRAVY & GREEN BEANS $17.95

SNAPPER CORDON BLEU PLATTER W/ CHOICE OF SIDE $21.95
(Fried Snapper Topped With Our Mustard Sauce, Ham & Provolone Cheese)

GROUPER SANDWICH Grilled OR Blackened & SIDE $21.95 OR PLATTER & SIDE $25.95

COBIA FISH SANDWICH Fried, Grilled or Blackened W/BLUE CHEESE SAUCE & SIDE $19.95 PLATTER $25.95

SWORDFISH PLATTER Fried, Grilled or Blackened W/BLUE CHEESE SAUCE & SIDE… $25.95

FRIED GROUPER FINGER PLATTER & SIDE… $21.95

JOHNNY SALAD TOPPED w/ OUR PRIME FILET MIGNON TIPS $23.95
GRILLED SALMON PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $23.95

FRIED FRESH SHUCKED OYSTER PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE….. $23.95

HOMEMADE MEATLOAF W/ MASHED POTATO/GRAVY & GREEN BEANS $18.95

HOMEMADE LASAGNA WITH GARLIC BREAD $17.95

STEAK NIGHT!!!
1” PRIME N.Y. STRIP STEAK & CHOICE OF SIDE…. $29.95

16OZ RIBEYE STEAK PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $34.95

8OZ PRIME FILET MIGNON STEAK & CHOICE OF SIDE… $42.95

WAGYU BURGER Topped W/ Maple Bacon Jam & Blue Cheese Sauce & SIDE… $18.95

HOGFISH SANDWICH Grilled, Blackened OR Fried & SIDE $21.95 OR PLATTER & SIDE $25.95

HOMEMADE SHRIMP BURGER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE… $19.95

FRIED ROYAL RED SHRIMP PLATTER & SIDE… $19.95

FRESH BAKED COOKIES: CHOCOLATE CHIP or SAMOA

STRAWBERRY SHORTCAKE A LA MODE
CHOCOLATE CREAM PIE
BANANA CREAM PIE
CHOCOLATE FUDGE LAVA CAKE A LA MODE
BANANA COOKIE BUTTER CHEESECAKE
MUD SLIDE! CAPPUCCINO FUDGE OR VANILLA PECAN TURTLE
(ICE CREAM ON AN OREO MUD CRUST)
JOHNNY’S HOMEMADE KEY LIME PIE
HOMEMADE CRUNCHY PEANUT BUTTER PIE

GERMAN BEERS ON TAP
Paulaner Hefeweizen Erdinger Dunkel Hacker Pschorr Oktoberfest

BEERS ON TAP
Coors Light Draft Iguana Bait Yuengling

PINOT GRIGIO CHARDONNAY CABERNET

MOSCATO WHITE ZINFINDEL

07/24/2026

🎉🕺IT'S FRIDAY😁 FISH TALES HAS COLD A/C & AMAZING HOMEMADE-HOMECOOKED FOOD🤤 STOP BY & SEE US OR CALL IN YOUR TO GO ORDER 😎

FRESH-MADE TO ORDER: Regular/Decaf Coffee & Espresso
FRESH SQUEEZED LIME-ADE

1/2 # STEAMED PEELED SHRIMP $13.95 OR
WHOLE POUND STEAMED PEELED SHRIMP $25.95

HOMEMADE FISH SPREAD $14.95
FRESH FRIED GREEN TOMOATOES W/ SIDE JOHNNY DRESSING $12.95
FRIED WISCONSIN CHEESECURDS W/ SIRRACHA MAYO $12.95

NEW: SURFSIDE VODKA ICED TEA- ISLAMORADA CITRUS ALE – TORPEDO IPA -COCONUT KEY LIME ALE -IPA VOODOO RANGER JUICY HAZE - SWEET WATER HAZY IPA NUTRL VODKA SELTZER WATERMELON- NUTRL VODKA SELTZER PINEAPPLE
FAMOSA BEER FROM GUATEMALA

HOMEMADE SOUP & CHOWDERS:
RED CONCH CHOWDER N.E. CLAM CHOWDER
CRAWDAD CHOWDER BEEF & BEAN CHILI split pea

SIDE CHOICES:
COLESLAW FRENCH FRIES NEW POTATOES POTATO SALAD
GREEN BEANS APPLE SAUCE BLACK BEANS & RICE

LUNCH SPECIALS
OUR SMOKED PORK CHOP W/ MASHED POTATOES/GRAVY & GREEN BEANS… $21.95

HOMEMADE SMOKED SALMON SALAD MELT ON WHITE OR RYE W/ CUP OF SOUP $16.95

THE WEINER SAMPLER – All Beef Hot Dog, Bratwurst & Italian Sausage WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $17.95

JOHNNY SALAD OR CAESAR SALAD TOPPED WITH SMOKED SALMON SALAD $18.95

GRILLED HAM & CHEESE ON WHITE OR MARBLED RYE W/ CUP OF SOUP $14.95

2 HOMEMADE CHILI DOGS WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $14.95

SNAPPER CORDON BLEU SANDWICH W/ CHOICE OF SIDE $21.95
(Fried Snapper Topped With Our Mustard Sauce, Ham & Provolone Cheese)

GROUPER SANDWICH Grilled OR Blackened & SIDE… $19.95 OR PLATTER & SIDE $24.95

COBIA FISH SANDWICH Fried, Grilled or Blackened W/BLUE CHEESE SAUCE & SIDE $19.95 PLATTER $24.95

SWORDFISH SANDWICH Fried, Grilled or Blackened W/BLUE CHEESE SAUCE & SIDE $19.95 PLATTER $24.95

HAM STEAK WITH MASHED POTATO/GRAVY & GREEN BEANS $17.95
16OZ NY STRIP STEAK PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $27.95

16OZ RIBEYE STEAK PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $34.95

WAGYU BURGER Topped W/ Maple Bacon Jam & Blue Cheese Sauce & SIDE… $17.95

FRIED GROUPER FINGER PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $21.95

FRIED FRESH SHUCKED OYSTER PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE… $23.95

HOMEMADE SHRIMP BURGER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE… $19.95

FRIED ROYAL RED SHRIMP PLATTER & SIDE… $19.95

HOGFISH SANDWICH Grilled, Blackened OR Fried & SIDE $19.95 OR PLATTER & SIDE $24.95

HONEY PEPPER PIMENTO CHEESE HALF POUND PRIME BURGER W/ CHOICE OF SIDE… $18.95
Half Pound Burger Topped With Our Honey Pepper Pimento Cheese

JOHNNY SALAD TOPPED w/ OUR PRIME FILET MIGNON TIPS… $23.95

HOMEMADE MEATLOAF W/ MASHED POTATO/GRAVY & GREEN BEANS $18.95

HONEY PEPPER PIMENTO CHEESE CHICKEN SANDWICH W/ CHOICE OF SIDE… $18.95
Fried Chicken Topped With Our Honey Pepper Pimento Cheese

FRESH BAKED COOKIES: CHOCOLATE CHIP or SAMOA

STRAWBERRY SHORTCAKE A LA MODE
CHOCOLATE CREAM PIE
BANANA CREAM PIE
CHOCOLATE FUDGE LAVA CAKE A LA MODE
BANANA COOKIE BUTTER CHEESECAKE
MUD SLIDE! CAPPUCCINO FUDGE OR VANILLA PECAN TURTLE
(ICE CREAM ON AN OREO MUD CRUST)
JOHNNY’S HOMEMADE KEY LIME PIE
HOMEMADE CRUNCHY PEANUT BUTTER PIE

GERMAN BEERS ON TAP
Paulaner Hefeweizen Erdinger Dunkel Hacker Pschorr Oktoberfest

BEERS ON TAP
Coors Light Draft Iguana Bait Yuengling
PINOT GRIGIO WHITE ZINFINDEL CHARDONNAY

MOSCATO CABERNET

Kick off your weekend! Our market is fully stocked and ready to meet your needs! We provide hand-cut steaks made to orde...
07/24/2026

Kick off your weekend! Our market is fully stocked and ready to meet your needs! We provide hand-cut steaks made to order, ensuring a perfect fit for your gatherings. Plus, our wide range of fish, seafood, and desserts are also available to enhance your meal plans. As a reliable one-stop shop, we offer homemade coleslaw, potato salad, chowders, and other essentials to make your dinner preparations effortless.

Prime Beef:
FILET MIGNON
RIBEYE
NY STRIP

**Fish Tales Market will be open today-Friday 11am-7:30pm and
tomorrow-Saturday 11am-3pm

07/23/2026

🍽👀FISH TALES DINNER SPECIALS FOR THURSDAY🌴🐟 COME SEE US OR CALL IN YOUR TO GO ORDER

FRESH-MADE TO ORDER: Regular/Decaf Coffee & Espresso
FRESH SQUEEZED LIME-ADE

1/2 # STEAMED PEELED SHRIMP $13.95 OR
WHOLE POUND STEAMED PEELED SHRIMP $25.95

HOMEMADE FISH SPREAD $14.95
FRESH FRIED GREEN TOMOATOES W/ SIDE JOHNNY DRESSING $12.95
FRIED WISCONSIN CHEESECURDS W/ SIRRACHA MAYO $12.95

NEW: SURFSIDE VODKA ICED TEA- ISLAMORADA CITRUS ALE – TORPEDO IPA -COCONUT KEY LIME ALE -IPA VOODOO RANGER JUICY HAZE - SWEET WATER HAZY IPA NUTRL VODKA SELTZER WATERMELON - NUTRL VODKA SELTZER PINEAPPLE
FAMOSA BEER FROM GUATEMALA

HOMEMADE SOUP & CHOWDERS:
RED CONCH CHOWDER N.E. CLAM CHOWDER
CRAWDAD CHOWDER BEEF & BEAN CHILI

SIDE CHOICES:
COLESLAW FRENCH FRIES NEW POTATOES POTATO SALAD
GREEN BEANS APPLE SAUCE BLACK BEANS & RICE

DINNER SPECIALS
HAM STEAK WITH MASHED POTATO/GRAVY & GREEN BEANS $17.95

HOMEMADE SMOKED SALMON MELT ON WHITE OR RYE W/ CUP OF SOUP $16.95

THE WEINER SAMPLER – All Beef Dog, Brat & Italian Sausage WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $17.95

JOHNNY SALAD OR CAESAR SALAD TOPPED WITH SMOKED SALMON SALAD $18.95

OUR SMOKED PORK CHOP W/ MASHED POTATOES/GRAVY & GREEN BEANS… $21.95

SNAPPER CORDON BLEU PLATTER W/ CHOICE OF SIDE $21.95
(Fried Snapper Topped With Our Mustard Sauce, Ham & Provolone Cheese)

GROUPER SANDWICH Grilled OR Blackened & SIDE $21.95 OR PLATTER & SIDE $25.95

COBIA FISH SANDWICH Fried, Grilled or Blackened W/BLUE CHEESE SAUCE & SIDE $19.95 PLATTER $25.95

SWORDFISH PLATTER Fried, Grilled or Blackened W/BLUE CHEESE SAUCE & SIDE… $25.95

FRIED GROUPER FINGER PLATTER & SIDE… $21.95

JOHNNY SALAD TOPPED w/ OUR PRIME FILET MIGNON TIPS $23.95
GRILLED SALMON PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $23.95

FRIED FRESH SHUCKED OYSTER PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE….. $23.95

HOMEMADE MEATLOAF W/ MASHED POTATO/GRAVY & GREEN BEANS $18.95

STEAK NIGHT!!!
1” PRIME N.Y. STRIP STEAK & CHOICE OF SIDE…. $29.95

16OZ RIBEYE STEAK PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $34.95

8OZ PRIME FILET MIGNON STEAK & CHOICE OF SIDE… $42.95

WAGYU BURGER Topped W/ Maple Bacon Jam & Blue Cheese Sauce & SIDE… $18.95

HOGFISH SANDWICH Grilled, Blackened OR Fried & SIDE $21.95 OR PLATTER & SIDE $25.95

HOMEMADE SHRIMP BURGER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE… $19.95

FRIED ROYAL RED SHRIMP PLATTER & SIDE… $19.95

FRESH BAKED COOKIES: CHOCOLATE CHIP or SAMOA

STRAWBERRY SHORTCAKE A LA MODE
CHOCOLATE CREAM PIE
BANANA CREAM PIE
CHOCOLATE FUDGE LAVA CAKE A LA MODE
BANANA COOKIE BUTTER CHEESECAKE
MUD SLIDE! CAPPUCCINO FUDGE OR VANILLA PECAN TURTLE
(ICE CREAM ON AN OREO MUD CRUST)
JOHNNY’S HOMEMADE KEY LIME PIE
HOMEMADE CRUNCHY PEANUT BUTTER PIE

GERMAN BEERS ON TAP
Paulaner Hefeweizen Erdinger Dunkel Hacker Pschorr Oktoberfest

BEERS ON TAP
Coors Light Draft Iguana Bait Yuengling

PINOT GRIGIO CHARDONNAY CABERNET

MOSCATO WHITE ZINFINDEL

07/23/2026

IT'S THURSDAY! TREAT YOURSELF TO LUNCH TODAY @ FISH TALES😁🌴🐟

FRESH-MADE TO ORDER: Regular/Decaf Coffee & Espresso
FRESH SQUEEZED LIME-ADE

1/2 # STEAMED PEELED SHRIMP $13.95 OR
WHOLE POUND STEAMED PEELED SHRIMP $25.95

HOMEMADE FISH SPREAD $14.95
FRESH FRIED GREEN TOMOATOES W/ SIDE JOHNNY DRESSING $12.95
FRIED WISCONSIN CHEESECURDS W/ SIRRACHA MAYO $12.95

NEW: SURFSIDE VODKA ICED TEA- ISLAMORADA CITRUS ALE – TORPEDO IPA -COCONUT KEY LIME ALE -IPA VOODOO RANGER JUICY HAZE - SWEET WATER HAZY IPA NUTRL VODKA SELTZER WATERMELON- NUTRL VODKA SELTZER PINEAPPLE
FAMOSA BEER FROM GUATEMALA

HOMEMADE SOUP & CHOWDERS:
RED CONCH CHOWDER N.E. CLAM CHOWDER
CRAWDAD CHOWDER BEEF & BEAN CHILI split pea

SIDE CHOICES:
COLESLAW FRENCH FRIES NEW POTATOES POTATO SALAD
GREEN BEANS APPLE SAUCE BLACK BEANS & RICE

LUNCH SPECIALS
HAM STEAK WITH MASHED POTATO/GRAVY & GREEN BEANS $17.95

HOMEMADE SMOKED SALMON SALAD MELT ON WHITE OR RYE W/ CUP OF SOUP $16.95

THE WEINER SAMPLER – All Beef Hot Dog, Bratwurst & Italian Sausage WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $17.95

JOHNNY SALAD OR CAESAR SALAD TOPPED WITH SMOKED SALMON SALAD $18.95

GRILLED HAM & CHEESE ON WHITE OR MARBLED RYE W/ CUP OF SOUP $14.95

2 HOMEMADE CHILI DOGS WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $14.95

SNAPPER CORDON BLEU SANDWICH W/ CHOICE OF SIDE $21.95
(Fried Snapper Topped With Our Mustard Sauce, Ham & Provolone Cheese)

GROUPER SANDWICH Grilled OR Blackened & SIDE… $19.95 OR PLATTER & SIDE $24.95

COBIA FISH SANDWICH Fried, Grilled or Blackened W/BLUE CHEESE SAUCE & SIDE $19.95 PLATTER $24.95

SWORDFISH SANDWICH Fried, Grilled or Blackened W/BLUE CHEESE SAUCE & SIDE $19.95 PLATTER $24.95

OUR SMOKED PORK CHOP W/ MASHED POTATOES/GRAVY & GREEN BEANS… $21.95
16OZ NY STRIP STEAK PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $27.95

WAGYU BURGER Topped W/ Maple Bacon Jam & Blue Cheese Sauce & SIDE… $17.95

FRIED GROUPER FINGER PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $21.95

FRIED FRESH SHUCKED OYSTER PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE… $23.95

HOMEMADE SHRIMP BURGER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE… $19.95

FRIED ROYAL RED SHRIMP PLATTER & SIDE… $19.95

HOGFISH SANDWICH Grilled, Blackened OR Fried & SIDE $19.95 OR PLATTER & SIDE $24.95

HONEY PEPPER PIMENTO CHEESE HALF POUND PRIME BURGER W/ CHOICE OF SIDE… $18.95
Half Pound Burger Topped With Our Honey Pepper Pimento Cheese

JOHNNY SALAD TOPPED w/ OUR PRIME FILET MIGNON TIPS… $23.95

HONEY PEPPER PIMENTO CHEESE CHICKEN SANDWICH W/ CHOICE OF SIDE… $18.95
Fried Chicken Topped With Our Honey Pepper Pimento Cheese

FRESH BAKED COOKIES: CHOCOLATE CHIP or SAMOA

STRAWBERRY SHORTCAKE A LA MODE
CHOCOLATE CREAM PIE
BANANA CREAM PIE
CHOCOLATE FUDGE LAVA CAKE A LA MODE
BANANA COOKIE BUTTER CHEESECAKE
MUD SLIDE! CAPPUCCINO FUDGE OR VANILLA PECAN TURTLE
(ICE CREAM ON AN OREO MUD CRUST)
JOHNNY’S HOMEMADE KEY LIME PIE
HOMEMADE CRUNCHY PEANUT BUTTER PIE

GERMAN BEERS ON TAP
Paulaner Hefeweizen Erdinger Dunkel Hacker Pschorr Oktoberfest

BEERS ON TAP
Coors Light Draft Iguana Bait Yuengling

PINOT GRIGIO WHITE ZINFINDEL CHARDONNAY

MOSCATO CABERNET

🤤 Are You Missing Stone Crabs Already? Having Friends & Family In Town That Missed The Stone Crab Season? Fish Tales Has...
07/23/2026

🤤 Are You Missing Stone Crabs Already? Having Friends & Family In Town That Missed The Stone Crab Season?

Fish Tales Has You Covered! 😎

Fresh Frozen On The Last Day Of Season. Cooked & Ready to go!🙌

🚨 Come Grab Them While They Last

🚨 Local Market with local & homemade selections of seafood, meats & more.🦀 We have a few fresh frozen Stone Crabs left i...
07/22/2026

🚨 Local Market with local & homemade selections of seafood, meats & more.

🦀 We have a few fresh frozen Stone Crabs left if you missed Stone Crab season.

Our homemade: Crab Cakes, Fish Dip
& Salmon Fish Dip, Coleslaw & Potato Salad are a MUST try.

One stop shop & you have your dinner plans😎

07/22/2026

🤔WONDERING WHERE TO TREAT YOURSELF TO LUNCH TODAY? FISH TALES HAS SOME AMAZING HOMEMADE LUNCH SPECIALS: HAM STEAK PLATTER..... SMOKED SALMON MELT.... OUR SMOKED PORK CHOP..... FRESH GROUPER.... FRIED OYSTERS & SO MUCH MORE😎

Regular Lunch Menu is also available... Something for everyone ❤

1/2 # STEAMED PEELED SHRIMP $13.95 OR
WHOLE POUND STEAMED PEELED SHRIMP $25.95

HOMEMADE FISH SPREAD $14.95
FRESH FRIED GREEN TOMOATOES W/ SIDE JOHNNY DRESSING $12.95
FRIED WISCONSIN CHEESECURDS W/ SIRRACHA MAYO $12.95

NEW: SURFSIDE VODKA ICED TEA- ISLAMORADA CITRUS ALE – TORPEDO IPA -COCONUT KEY LIME ALE -IPA VOODOO RANGER JUICY HAZE - SWEET WATER HAZY IPA NUTRL VODKA SELTZER WATERMELON- NUTRL VODKA SELTZER PINEAPPLE
FAMOSA BEER FROM GUATEMALA

HOMEMADE SOUP & CHOWDERS:
RED CONCH CHOWDER N.E. CLAM CHOWDER
CRAWDAD CHOWDER BEEF & BEAN CHILI split pea

SIDE CHOICES:
COLESLAW FRENCH FRIES NEW POTATOES POTATO SALAD
GREEN BEANS APPLE SAUCE BLACK BEANS & RICE

LUNCH SPECIALS
HOMEMADE SMOKED SALMON SALAD MELT ON WHITE OR RYE W/ CUP OF SOUP $16.95

HAM STEAK WITH MASHED POTATO/GRAVY & GREEN BEANS $17.95

THE WEINER SAMPLER – All Beef Dog, Brat & Italian Sausage WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $17.95

JOHNNY SALAD OR CAESAR SALAD TOPPED WITH SMOKED SALMON SALAD $18.95

GRILLED HAM & CHEESE ON WHITE OR MARBLED RYE W/ CUP OF SOUP $14.95

2 HOMEMADE CHILI DOGS WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $14.95

SNAPPER CORDON BLEU SANDWICH W/ CHOICE OF SIDE $21.95
(Fried Snapper Topped With Our Mustard Sauce, Ham & Provolone Cheese)

GROUPER SANDWICH Grilled OR Blackened & SIDE… $19.95 OR PLATTER & SIDE $24.95

COBIA FISH SANDWICH Fried, Grilled or Blackened W/BLUE CHEESE SAUCE & SIDE $19.95 PLATTER $24.95

SWORDFISH SANDWICH Fried, Grilled or Blackened W/BLUE CHEESE SAUCE & SIDE $19.95 PLATTER $24.95

OUR SMOKED PORK CHOP W/ MASHED POTATOES/GRAVY & GREEN BEANS… $21.95

16OZ NY STRIP STEAK PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $27.95

WAGYU BURGER Topped W/ Maple Bacon Jam & Blue Cheese Sauce & SIDE… $17.95

FRIED GROUPER FINGER PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $21.95

FRIED FRESH SHUCKED OYSTER PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE… $23.95

HOMEMADE SHRIMP BURGER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE… $19.95

FRIED ROYAL RED SHRIMP PLATTER & SIDE… $19.95

HOGFISH SANDWICH Grilled, Blackened OR Fried & SIDE $19.95 OR PLATTER & SIDE $24.95

HONEY PEPPER PIMENTO CHEESE HALF POUND PRIME BURGER W/ CHOICE OF SIDE… $18.95
Half Pound Burger Topped With Our Honey Pepper Pimento Cheese

JOHNNY SALAD TOPPED w/ OUR PRIME FILET MIGNON TIPS… $23.95

HONEY PEPPER PIMENTO CHEESE CHICKEN SANDWICH W/ CHOICE OF SIDE… $18.95
Fried Chicken Topped With Our Honey Pepper Pimento Cheese

FRESH BAKED COOKIES: CHOCOLATE CHIP or SAMOA

STRAWBERRY SHORTCAKE A LA MODE
CHOCOLATE CREAM PIE
BANANA CREAM PIE
CHOCOLATE FUDGE LAVA CAKE A LA MODE
BANANA COOKIE BUTTER CHEESECAKE
MUD SLIDE! CAPPUCCINO FUDGE OR VANILLA PECAN TURTLE
(ICE CREAM ON AN OREO MUD CRUST)
JOHNNY’S HOMEMADE KEY LIME PIE
HOMEMADE CRUNCHY PEANUT BUTTER PIE

GERMAN BEERS ON TAP
Paulaner Hefeweizen Erdinger Dunkel Hacker Pschorr Oktoberfest

BEERS ON TAP
Coors Light Draft Iguana Bait Yuengling

PINOT GRIGIO WHITE ZINFINDEL CHARDONNAY

MOSCATO CABERNET

07/21/2026

DINNER SPECIALS FOR FISH TALES 🌴🐟

FRESH-MADE TO ORDER: Regular/Decaf Coffee & Espresso
FRESH SQUEEZED LIME-ADE

1/2 # STEAMED PEELED SHRIMP $13.95 OR
WHOLE POUND STEAMED PEELED SHRIMP $25.95

HOMEMADE FISH SPREAD $14.95
FRESH FRIED GREEN TOMOATOES W/ SIDE JOHNNY DRESSING $12.95
FRIED WISCONSIN CHEESECURDS W/ SIRRACHA MAYO $12.95

NEW: SURFSIDE VODKA ICED TEA- ISLAMORADA CITRUS ALE – TORPEDO IPA -COCONUT KEY LIME ALE -IPA VOODOO RANGER JUICY HAZE - SWEET WATER HAZY IPA NUTRL VODKA SELTZER WATERMELON - NUTRL VODKA SELTZER PINEAPPLE
FAMOSA BEER FROM GUATEMALA

HOMEMADE SOUP & CHOWDERS:
RED CONCH CHOWDER N.E. CLAM CHOWDER
CRAWDAD CHOWDER BEEF & BEAN CHILI

SIDE CHOICES:
COLESLAW FRENCH FRIES NEW POTATOES POTATO SALAD
GREEN BEANS APPLE SAUCE BLACK BEANS & RICE

DINNER SPECIALS
HOMEMADE SMOKED SALMON MELT ON WHITE OR RYE W/ CUP OF SOUP $16.95

HAM STEAK WITH MASHED POTATO/GRAVY & GREEN BEANS $17.95

THE WEINER SAMPLER – All Beef Dog, Brat & Italian Sausage WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $17.95

JOHNNY SALAD OR CAESAR SALAD TOPPED WITH SMOKED SALMON SALAD $18.95

COBIA FISH SANDWICH Fried, Grilled or Blackened W/BLUE CHEESE SAUCE & SIDE $19.95 PLATTER $25.95

SWORDFISH PLATTER Fried, Grilled or Blackened W/BLUE CHEESE SAUCE & SIDE… $25.95

OUR SMOKED PORK CHOP W/ MASHED POTATOES/GRAVY & GREEN BEANS… $21.95

SNAPPER CORDON BLEU PLATTER W/ CHOICE OF SIDE $21.95
(Fried Snapper Topped With Our Mustard Sauce, Ham & Provolone Cheese)

GROUPER SANDWICH Grilled OR Blackened & SIDE $21.95 OR PLATTER & SIDE $25.95

FRIED GROUPER FINGER PLATTER & SIDE… $21.95

JOHNNY SALAD TOPPED w/ OUR PRIME FILET MIGNON TIPS $23.95

GRILLED SALMON PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $23.95

FRIED FRESH SHUCKED OYSTER PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE….. $23.95

STEAK NIGHT!!!
1” PRIME N.Y. STRIP STEAK & CHOICE OF SIDE…. $29.95

16OZ RIBEYE STEAK PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $34.95

8OZ PRIME FILET MIGNON STEAK & CHOICE OF SIDE… $42.95

WAGYU BURGER Topped W/ Maple Bacon Jam & Blue Cheese Sauce & SIDE… $18.95

HOGFISH SANDWICH Grilled, Blackened OR Fried & SIDE $21.95 OR PLATTER & SIDE $25.95

HOMEMADE SHRIMP BURGER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE… $19.95

FRIED ROYAL RED SHRIMP PLATTER & SIDE… $19.95

FRESH BAKED COOKIES: CHOCOLATE CHIP or SAMOA

STRAWBERRY SHORTCAKE A LA MODE
CHOCOLATE CREAM PIE
BANANA CREAM PIE
CHOCOLATE FUDGE LAVA CAKE A LA MODE
BANANA COOKIE BUTTER CHEESECAKE
MUD SLIDE! CAPPUCCINO FUDGE OR VANILLA PECAN TURTLE
(ICE CREAM ON AN OREO MUD CRUST)
JOHNNY’S HOMEMADE KEY LIME PIE
HOMEMADE CRUNCHY PEANUT BUTTER PIE

GERMAN BEERS ON TAP
Paulaner Hefeweizen Erdinger Dunkel Hacker Pschorr Oktoberfest

BEERS ON TAP
Coors Light Draft Iguana Bait Yuengling

PINOT GRIGIO CHARDONNAY CABERNET

MOSCATO WHITE ZINFINDEL

07/21/2026

🌴🐟TASTY TUESDAY at Fish Tales Market & Eatery! 🐟🌴
Looking for a fresh, homemade lunch in the heart of the Florida Keys? Skip the fast food and treat yourself to a meal that's made fresh to order😎

LUNCH SPECIALS:

FRESH-MADE TO ORDER: Regular/Decaf Coffee & Espresso
FRESH SQUEEZED LIME-ADE

1/2 # STEAMED PEELED SHRIMP $13.95 OR
WHOLE POUND STEAMED PEELED SHRIMP $25.95

HOMEMADE FISH SPREAD $14.95
FRESH FRIED GREEN TOMOATOES W/ SIDE JOHNNY DRESSING $12.95
FRIED WISCONSIN CHEESECURDS W/ SIRRACHA MAYO $12.95

NEW: SURFSIDE VODKA ICED TEA- ISLAMORADA CITRUS ALE – TORPEDO IPA -COCONUT KEY LIME ALE -IPA VOODOO RANGER JUICY HAZE - SWEET WATER HAZY IPA NUTRL VODKA SELTZER WATERMELON- NUTRL VODKA SELTZER PINEAPPLE
FAMOSA BEER FROM GUATEMALA

HOMEMADE SOUP & CHOWDERS:
RED CONCH CHOWDER N.E. CLAM CHOWDER
CRAWDAD CHOWDER BEEF & BEAN CHILI split pea

SIDE CHOICES:
COLESLAW FRENCH FRIES NEW POTATOES POTATO SALAD
GREEN BEANS APPLE SAUCE BLACK BEANS & RICE

LUNCH SPECIALS
HOMEMADE SMOKED SALMON SALAD MELT ON WHITE OR RYE W/ CUP OF SOUP $16.95

HAM STEAK WITH MASHED POTATO/GRAVY & GREEN BEANS $17.95

THE WEINER SAMPLER – All Beef Dog, Brat & Italian Sausage WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $17.95

JOHNNY SALAD OR CAESAR SALAD TOPPED WITH SMOKED SALMON SALAD $18.95

GRILLED HAM & CHEESE ON WHITE OR MARBLED RYE W/ CUP OF SOUP $14.95

2 HOMEMADE CHILI DOGS WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $14.95

SNAPPER CORDON BLEU SANDWICH W/ CHOICE OF SIDE $21.95
(Fried Snapper Topped With Our Mustard Sauce, Ham & Provolone Cheese)

GROUPER SANDWICH Grilled OR Blackened & SIDE… $19.95 OR PLATTER & SIDE $24.95

COBIA FISH SANDWICH Fried, Grilled or Blackened W/BLUE CHEESE SAUCE & SIDE $19.95 PLATTER $24.95

SWORDFISH SANDWICH Fried, Grilled or Blackened W/BLUE CHEESE SAUCE & SIDE $19.95 PLATTER $24.95

OUR SMOKED PORK CHOP W/ MASHED POTATOES/GRAVY & GREEN BEANS… $21.95
16OZ RIBEYE STEAK PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $34.95

FRIED GROUPER FINGER PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $21.95

FRIED FRESH SHUCKED OYSTER PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE… $23.95

HOMEMADE SHRIMP BURGER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE… $19.95

FRIED ROYAL RED SHRIMP PLATTER & SIDE… $19.95

HOGFISH SANDWICH Grilled, Blackened OR Fried & SIDE $19.95 OR PLATTER & SIDE $24.95

WAGYU BURGER Topped W/ Maple Bacon Jam & Blue Cheese Sauce & SIDE… $17.95

HONEY PEPPER PIMENTO CHEESE HALF POUND PRIME BURGER W/ CHOICE OF SIDE… $18.95
Half Pound Burger Topped With Our Honey Pepper Pimento Cheese

JOHNNY SALAD TOPPED w/ OUR PRIME FILET MIGNON TIPS… $23.95

HONEY PEPPER PIMENTO CHEESE CHICKEN SANDWICH W/ CHOICE OF SIDE… $18.95
Fried Chicken Topped With Our Honey Pepper Pimento Cheese

FRESH BAKED COOKIES: CHOCOLATE CHIP or SAMOA

STRAWBERRY SHORTCAKE A LA MODE
CHOCOLATE CREAM PIE
BANANA CREAM PIE
CHOCOLATE FUDGE LAVA CAKE A LA MODE
MUD SLIDE! CAPPUCCINO FUDGE OR VANILLA PECAN TURTLE
(ICE CREAM ON AN OREO MUD CRUST)
JOHNNY’S HOMEMADE KEY LIME PIE
HOMEMADE CRUNCHY PEANUT BUTTER PIE

GERMAN BEERS ON TAP
Paulaner Hefeweizen Erdinger Dunkel Hacker Pschorr Oktoberfest

BEERS ON TAP
Coors Light Draft Iguana Bait Yuengling

PINOT GRIGIO WHITE ZINFINDEL CHARDONNAY

MOSCATO CABERNET

Address

11711 Overseas Highway
Marathon, FL
33050

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 7:30pm
Tuesday 11am - 7:30pm
Wednesday 11am - 7:30pm
Thursday 11am - 7:30pm
Friday 11am - 7:30pm
Saturday 11am - 3pm

Telephone

+13057439196

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Fish Tales Market and Eatery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Fish Tales Market and Eatery:

Shortcuts

Share

Category