What are the opening hours?

Monday 8am - 5pm Tuesday 8am - 5pm Wednesday 8am - 5pm Thursday 8am - 5pm Friday 8am - 5pm Saturday 8am - 5pm Sunday 8am - 5pm

SmallPie

Fresh, hand-crafted sweet & savory baked goods made with local ingredients in Bay View.
(210)

03/04/2026

Our favorite holiday is nearly here - we are gettin’ the pies ready for PI Day on March 14th

01/30/2026

To all in our community who are protesting we stand in solidarity with you today!! As a small, independent, women-owned business we will be open today and here with our hearts and doors open and ready to welcome you all!

Starting today and all through February we are donating $1 from every purchase of our giant chocolate chip cookies and triple threat cookies to “chip in” towards the work of .

Stop in and see us, warm up your soul with a big cookie. And if you are out today, support the small independent businesses around you, especially the ones our immigrant neighbors run. Because our community would not be as beautiful and vibrant without them.

12/22/2025

HAPPY HOLIDAYS FRIENDS!

We will be OPEN Christmas Eve:
Wednesday 12/24
from 8a-12p

We’ve got all the goodies you need, but if you’re looking for something special, our sister location , is still taking last minute orders for PIE! Give em a call at
📞(414) 242-6389

From our hearts to yours, we wish you the merriest season our small pies can offer 💟

See you soon!
🥧

11/25/2025

HAPPY THANKSGIVING!

We will be CLOSED on Thanksgiving, but reopen BRIGHT and EARLY to fuel all your BLACK FRIDAY NEEDS!
(Just remember to shop small - local businesses need your help now more than ever!)

If you’re in need of a last minute PANIC pie, has got you covered!
📞 Give them a call at 414-242-6389

From our BIG hearts to yours, we’re grateful for your support!

11/14/2025

THANKSGIVING PIE ORDERING IS AVAILABLE NOW! 🥧

It’s November and we are reflecting on how grateful we are for our community! We went to share the sweetness with you and your loved ones this Thanksgiving.

All The Pickup Details:
📍Pickup Location: Honeypie Bakeshop (inside our Palomino location)
🗓️Pickup Window: Sunday 11/23 - Saturday11/29
⏰Pickup Time: 9 am to 9 pm daily

For more, visit the link in our bio.

Happy Thanksgiving, Milwaukee! 🦃

11/02/2025

The Pumpkin Spiced Latte Pie is here for November’s Pie of the Month. Whipped cream cheese-pumpkin filling with Fall spices and a touch of coffee in our handmade shortbread crust. Topped with real whipped cream. Available at all our locations and for special order online.

09/17/2025

SEPTEMBER
Cheeseburger, but make it PORTABLE!
🍔↪️

This handpie of the month is here with all your burger favorites, wrapped in a flaky, buttery pastry crust. Ground beef, cheddar, ketchup, & mustard, but you’ll have to grab your own pickles ( has our favorite in town!)

Perfect with a soda on our patio before the autumn leaves start falling 🍂

SEE YOU SOON!

08/15/2025

AUGUST

Tony’s Buffalo Chicken Handpie just dropped! 🔥🥧

Inspired by his fave NYC buffalo tenders, this beauty’s packed with chicken, potato, blue cheese & house hot sauce.

Pro tip: grab an extra bottle of sauce for dipping!

More details in our fancy new blog (which you can find at the link in our bio)

SEE YOU SOON!!
🔥

05/31/2025

OH NO

Our oven decided it needed a break (same)
Monday is the earliest we can get someone out.

Treats, plants, and cold handpies are still available!!

Thanks for your understanding 💛

03/06/2025

Oh, RATS!

While we are visited by a lot of dogs, we welcome friends of ALL shapes and sizes!

Introducing our PET(s) OF THE MONTH:
🏆MAC & CHEESE🏅

These little goofballs are just as loving as their owners and we are lucky to have met them!
Congrats to the whole family.

In collaboration with , Mac & Cheese will be receiving
🧀 an adorable gift set from our favorite pet shop
🧀 a $15 gift card to SmallPie to share with the family

CONGRATS AGAIN!
Think your mutt, cat, ginuea pig, etc has what it takes to be Pet of the Month? Bring ‘em over and strike a pose! Tag us in the best shot for a chance to win!

Address

2504 E. Oklahoma Avenue
Milwaukee, WI
53207

Opening Hours

Monday	8am - 5pm
Tuesday	8am - 5pm
Wednesday	8am - 5pm
Thursday	8am - 5pm
Friday	8am - 5pm
Saturday	8am - 5pm
Sunday	8am - 5pm

Telephone

+14147637067

Website

http://smallpiemke.com/, https://bio.site/pie_incorporated

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when SmallPie posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to SmallPie:

Shortcuts

Address
Telephone
Opening Hours
Alerts
Contact The Business
Claim ownership or report listing

Want your business to be the top-listed Restaurant in Milwaukee?