Sauce Instagram Italian food with American style. Superb thin crust pizza and tasty pasta dishes made from scratch with third generation family recipes.
(234)

We quietly deployed a mythical   to Highlands, NC over the weekend. It rained the whole time. Nonetheless, we surprised ...
05/26/2026

We quietly deployed a mythical to Highlands, NC over the weekend. It rained the whole time. Nonetheless, we surprised and delighted both locals and tourists alike. A birthday party was thrown. Great memories were made.

We will return soon.

In the meantime, we’re still on the lookout for a Sunday/Monday kitchen as close to S. Church St. as possible. If anyone has a lead, let us know.

If we do a popup somewhere soon — for a day at another restaurant when they’re closed — is there a particular day of the...
04/27/2026

If we do a popup somewhere soon — for a day at another restaurant when they’re closed — is there a particular day of the week that you’d like to see it happen? It would most likely have to be on a Sunday, Monday, or maybe Tuesday.

If you visited the restaurant between 2020 and 2023, you might’ve been served by Macey.She has been fairly busy since th...
04/19/2026

If you visited the restaurant between 2020 and 2023, you might’ve been served by Macey.

She has been fairly busy since then.

Tune in Tuesday at 7pm on Fox for a mere glimpse.

04/05/2026

Happy Easter, everybody.

And hello again. We have been very busy behind the scenes. More on that soon.
For now, a casual survey question:

In your opinion — which could be humble or not — what’s the one thing that we absolutely should not even consider reopening without?

In 12+ years in business, we probably dished out 12x more to-go boxes than dessert orders.Not a complaint — mere observa...
03/15/2026

In 12+ years in business, we probably dished out 12x more to-go boxes than dessert orders.

Not a complaint — mere observation.

We opened fourteen years ago on April 12 offering a pair of “homemade” pies: lemon icebox and peanut butter.

(Full disclosure: store-bought graham cracker pie crusts.)

The recipe for the PB Pie filling was handwritten and thumb-tacked to the wall the day before the restaurant opened — and the sheet might not have been removed until a year after it closed.

The last slice was sold more than a decade ago.

Please enjoy.

——
:
1 c. peanut butter (chunky or not)
1.5 c. whipped topping (heavy or not)
1 c. confectioners sugar
1/4 c. sugar (🙈)
8 oz. cream cheese (room temp, broken apart)
*optional: semi sweet mini morsels

1. Mix ingredients — thoroughly — don’t slack. Smooth out all the cream cheese lumps, even the little ones. Elbow grease helps.
2. Add fully mixed result to graham cracker pie crust (chocolate if desired).
3. Refrigerate overnight.

Could there be a better or worse time for an owner introduction than roughly 30 months after the business vanished myste...
03/14/2026

Could there be a better or worse time for an owner introduction than roughly 30 months after the business vanished mysteriously?

Probably.

Hi.
I’m Tyler.
Apparently I have a knack for layering flavors that bloom late.

By October of 2010, I was halfway through age 30 when a buddy from back home lent me $10,000.

Wrote a dense business plan and took it to Regions — they said no.
Went to Pinnacle — they said go, holding the borrowed funds in a CD in exchange for access to a $45,000 line of credit.

Two personal credit cards maxed out to $15,000 total.

Add untold hours of free labor thanks to an excited bunch of family, friends, and acquaintances.
Throw in a handful of lucky breaks.
Six months later, doors opened.

Looking back, the math probably shouldn’t have worked.

Guess sometimes all it takes is a modest pile of cash, a questionable level of confidence, and just enough people willing to say, “Sure, why not.”

That’s pretty much how this started.

It’s barely the backstory.

The restaurant gradually became something closer to a beloved book series. Or a long-running TV show. Or a complex multiplayer video game where everybody skipped the tutorial. Or a dream.

People made memories that refuse to fade:

* The folks who discovered us and told others to try the food
* The youth who wandered in off the street and stumbled into a job
* The woman ordered the Grilled Chicken Salad (no tomato) for twelve straight years
* The cousin who took the first — and could’ve taken the last — order fulfilled
* The homeschooled boys who started out hiding in the sink, incapable of cooking a Pop-Tart, only to grow up and master every job in the kitchen
* The first stranger hired, a server with two shifts a week, who also once wore the pizza costume and boogied down by the road
* The unpaid worker who’d panic if a table sat and waited longer than zero seconds for menus, silverware, straws (AKA ‘The Sauce Mom’)
* The person who walked half a mile from work multiple times a week for Buffalo Sticks with quadruple bleu cheese dressing
* The best server in town,
who worked a crazy double
while 8 months pregnant
on our busiest day ever:
Mother’s Day, 2023
* The lad who went from dishwasher to server to Marine to regular customer and police officer
* The serial burglar who threw a brick through the front door only to steal nothing
* The girl who stood on an old upside-down pot to work the oven
* The men who softly wept when the Kitchen Sink went away
* The customer who clipped nails at a table
* The couple who celebrated anniversaries
* The handyman who fixed stuff for pizzas
* The guy always on a laptop in the corner
* The neighbors who chose to support us
* The child who ate 19 packs of Splenda
* The kid who fell in love with broccoli
* The baby who napped in a box
* The few who knew the price
* The two who could do it all
* The ones who never left
* The debt still owed
* The fans, really

See, Sauce didn’t have a single hero.
It had a great supporting cast.

The place itself was the hero. ⭐️

And there’s a lot more to the story.

So, if the hunger is real, then we just may find a way to restart our heart and keep feeding.

Anything is possible.

Stay tuned.

♥️🙏💚

For fun, let’s just say we’re able to figure out a creative way to return.We’d need a new location.Any bright ideas?
03/12/2026

For fun, let’s just say we’re able to figure out a creative way to return.

We’d need a new location.

Any bright ideas?

Many have asked if our little eatery will ever return.Recently the answer became:“Hmm… maybe.”We have been taking a seri...
02/27/2026

Many have asked if our little eatery will ever return.
Recently the answer became:
“Hmm… maybe.”

We have been taking a serious look at what a reboot could be — larger footprint, stronger systems, same heart, and (believe it or not) upgraded alfredo.

Given how much the landscape has changed, it would require the right partner — just one — who understands durable businesses and community-rooted growth.

If that’s you, reach out.

12/02/2023

Here’s a step-by-step guide to dealing with an unbaked pasta container.

Step 1, plan ahead.

2. Bring pasta as close to room temp as your emotional configuration will allow without sacrificing sanity.

3. Preheat oven to a degree that reflects the temperature of the pasta in question. (420-550.) Every oven is different, but 15-25 minutes should do the trick. Frozen pastas cook better/slower at lower temps, whereas room-temp dishes may “sing” under fast/high heat.

4. Be present. Observe progress. Look for signs of doneness. Remove from oven once the food looks appetizing.

5. And then take a bite. Has it been heated thoroughly? Does the texture satisfy? If not, then re-insert. But if so, then dig in.

6. Profit.

7. Crave.

8. Dream.

9. Breathe.

Anybody in the mood to acquire a little “goldmine”? 😂Wait. Let’s back up.Last week, when we finally mentioned our window...
11/30/2023

Anybody in the mood to acquire a little “goldmine”? 😂

Wait. Let’s back up.

Last week, when we finally mentioned our window sadly closing, as it turns out, we may have been mistaken. Thanks to a very generous extension of the already incredible grace period awarded by our landlord, it appears that the business (as it sits still currently in the only location it has ever known) remains available for purchase—through a professional business broker who performed a thorough valuation—but just for one more day.

In other words, “Sauce” could be reopened before January (technically) with the same great food…by someone other than us.

This isn’t an attempt to sell. Expectations are nonexistent. Didn’t even realize selling was on the table. But given the arrival of unexpected news, we’d simply be remiss not to relay the chance. You know? Just in case.

As such, here’s some info you maybe don’t see everyday:

Gross sales in 2019: $351,000.
2020/Covid: 285k. Yikes.
2021: 392. Solid bounce-back.
2022: 501! Whoa…
In 2023, before shutting down in August, Sauce was on pace to exceed 650. Yeah, um, neat.

Apparent value according to industry standards (or whatever): almost 600k. 🤯

Who knew!? Certainly not longtime ownership. (Although the potential of pinching pennies has since been acknowledged.)

Sale price: less than half the apparent value. (Nope, this isn’t exactly normal.)

And it would appear that new ownership prospects—namely anyone interested in math and financial data—might determine that expected earnings should easily total a million dollars over the next 5 years.

Sauce survived Covid, had been absolutely booming, and was primed for an expansive takeoff, so of course we had to move and start giving away food.

But weirdly, the unorthodox trail we seek to blaze may leave behind a fleeting, golden opportunity for somebody else. 🩶

Start the clock—25 hours left to acquire Sauce and resurrect the business like a fiery phoenix.

(Should any interested parties actually emerge, just let us know and we’ll connect you with the aforementioned broker.)

Address

2858 S Church Street
Murfreesboro, TN
37127

Opening Hours

Tuesday 11am - 8pm
Wednesday 11am - 8pm
Thursday 11am - 8pm
Friday 11am - 9pm
Saturday 11am - 9pm
Sunday 11am - 8pm

Telephone

+16156248258

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Sauce posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Share