https://www.facebook.com/196827626856487/

Sugar Hill Creamery

Home
United States
New York, NY
Sugar Hill Creamery

Call Directions

Contact information, map and directions, contact form, opening hours, services, ratings, photos, videos and announcements from Sugar Hill Creamery, Ice Cream Shop, 55 Water Street, New York, NY.

11/11/2026

Now scooping Goddess Pomona! 🍎🍂

Made with apple c***r and a vegan caramel swirl, this dairy-free flavor is the perfect way to satisfy all your fall apple cravings!

Available at all locations:

📍184 Lenox Avenue 📍3629 Broadway 📍1642 Lexington Avenue

***r

11/10/2026

Looking for a fun non-alcoholic option for your next holiday party? Bring Sugar Hill Creamery’s hot chocolate to your celebration. 🍫☕️

Rich, cozy, and topped with delicious, house-made marshmallow fluff, it’s the perfect treat for your guests.

Submit a hot chocolate catering inquiry through the link in our bio!

11/09/2026

Pecan pie lovers, this one’s for you!

Our Bourbon Pecan Ice Cream Pie combines butter pecan ice cream, bourbon, and a hint of Ethiopian berbere spice with honey-glazed pecans in every bite.

Preorder yours on our website!

📌 Place your order by Thursday, November 19th.

Pick up between Friday, November 20th and Wednesday, November 25th. 🥃🥧

11/08/2026

Now scooping our walnut cream, pumpkin bread, and blueberry apple swirl for the perfect blend of cozy fall flavors! 🍂

We created this flavor using California walnut cream as part of Discover California Walnuts Week, in partnership with California Walnuts and StarChefs ! Try it, scan the QR code on the postcard at the counter to share your feedback, and you could win a $1,500 cash prize!

Ask for Fallout at any Sugar Hill Creamery location:

📍184 Lenox Avenue
📍3629 Broadway
📍1642 Lexington Avenue

11/07/2026

Now serving The Gasby 🍑

Our housemade peach cobbler with bourbon peaches, warm spices, and sweet biscuit rounds. This is a take-and-bake that you can enjoy at home served warm with a scoop of cinnamon ice cream.

Available at all locations!

📍184 Lenox Avenue
📍3629 Broadway
📍1642 Lexington Avenue

11/07/2026

Now serving our Haitian Campfire 🔥

A crème brûlée custard tart with a graham cracker crust, a scoop of our Haitian Hot Chocolate Ice Cream, and a dollop of torched marshmallow fluff.

📍184 Lenox Avenue 📍3629 Broadway 📍1642 Lexington Avenue

11/06/2026

Your Thanksgiving dessert hat arrived covered! Our ice cream pies are now available for preorder at all Sugar Hill Creamery locations.

Swipe to see this year’s lineup:

🥃 Bourbon Pecan Ice Cream Pie
🍠 Sweet Potato Ice Cream Pie
🍑 Peach Cobbler Ice Cream Pie

Order on our website by Thursday, November 19. Pickup begins Friday, November 20.

11/01/2026

A little something sweet for marathon day! 🏃🏾‍♀️☕️

We’re celebrating the NYC Marathon with FREE hot chocolate samples from our brand-new cart! Find us around mile 21 for a taste, or grab a full cup at our Sugar Hill Creamery locations along the route!

📍184 Lenox Avenue 📍1642 Lexington Avenue

10/31/2026

It’s our favorite time of year—Halloween and Marathon Weekend. Stop by any Sugar Hill Creamery for a treat will be handing out candy until it runs out.

Tag us in your pictures in front of the store if you stop by for candy!

We love to see all of your costumes.

Visit us this weekend to enjoy our newest flavor to the case “King François.”

It’s a cereal milk flavor that includes cubes of crunchy corn flavor Nutella-marshmallow folded throughout.

It was created by LeeRoi, one of our 3K neighbors!

And, catch us tomorrow somewhere around mile 21 for free samples of hot chocolate!! Shout out to everyone running, including our very own co-founder Petrushka Bazin Larsen.

Catch us tomorrow somewhere around mile 21 for free samples of hot chocolate.

10/30/2026

Meet King François, created by LeeRoi from 3K, our Back-to-School Flavor Competition winner: cereal milk ice cream with cornflake brittle and Nutella marshmallow.

Available tomorrow at all Sugar Hill Creamery locations, while supplies last. Come treat yourself to a Halloween scoop! 🎃

📍184 Lenox Avenue
📍3629 Broadway
📍1642 Lexington Avenue

Address

55 Water Street
New York, NY
11201

Telephone

+1 212-634-9004

Website

facebook.com

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Sugar Hill Creamery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.