What are the opening hours?

Monday 7am - 2pm Tuesday 7am - 2pm Wednesday 7am - 2pm Thursday 7am - 2pm Friday 7am - 2pm Saturday 7am - 2pm Sunday 7am - 2pm

The Bagel Mill Petaluma

Name: The Bagel Mill Petaluma
Address: 212 Western Avenue, Petaluma, CA, 94952, US
Telephone: +17079818010
Price range: $$

Home
United States
Petaluma, CA
The Bagel Mill Petaluma

Organic, sourdough bagels made with freshly milled flour. Handmade in Petaluma, CA.

07/25/2026

Weekends are made for sourdough cinnamon rolls 🤍

Our naturally leavened cinnamon rolls are fresh from the oven every weekend, but they never stick around for long. They sell out early, so stop by first thing to grab yours!

Pair one with our Salt Bagel (Sundays only!) and an iced strawberry matcha for the ultimate Sunday lineup ☀️🍓🍵

07/22/2026

What’s my favorite bagel?! 🥁

A true classic: everything bagel with scallion cream cheese. Sometimes I add cucumber 🥒 and sometimes I get green olive cream cheese instead. But an everything bagel is perfection to me: salty, garlicky, chewy and soft inside (and no caraway or fennel seeds in our mix— I have strong opinions about that 😋).

My daughter’s favorite: cinnamon raisin with nothing on it. I don’t get it, but maybe one day I’ll convert her to team Everything!

📸 Dylan Pacio

07/18/2026

Beautiful fresh strawberry brioche rolls are here for the weekend! 🍓

Made with gorgeous strawberries from Stony Point Strawberry Farm, these seasonal rolls showcase one of our favorite doughs. Our brioche is 100% naturally leavened and made with 40% freshly milled whole wheat from our own mill, creating a light, fluffy texture with incredible flavor and a tender crumb.

Each roll is topped with sweet farmer’s cheese, buttery oat crumble, and the sweetest local strawberries 💫☁️

07/10/2026

Tomato season is finally here! 🍅✨

A huge thank you to SunBlaze Ranch for these beautiful, peak-season tomatoes. Good ingredients, kept simple, and served on a fresh, chewy, sourdough bagel. That’s our favorite kind of summer. ☀️

🍅 Tomato Toast
Garlic confit aioli, farmer’s market tomatoes, garlic oil, flaky salt, cracked pepper & fresh basil.

🍅 Caprese Toast
Fresh mozzarella, farmer’s market tomatoes, balsamic reduction, flaky salt, cracked pepper & fresh basil.

Fresh, local, and only here while tomato season lasts!

07/05/2026

COLD FOAM has officially launched! 🚀☁️

Add it to any of your favorite drinks for a rich, sweet, creamy finish.

Our newest summer favorite? 🥥 The Creamy Coconut Cold Brew with Cold Foam. We make our creamy coconut syrup with sweetened condensed coconut milk and rich coconut cream, then top it with silky cold foam. Time to treat yourself!

07/04/2026

Happy 7 year BAGEL MILL BIRTHDAY! (Also HBD, USA 🇺🇸😆)

Here’s a photo of a very pregnant me during the height of COVID as a reminder of times past 😜. We opened on July 3, 2019 and today almost slipped by without me remembering! We’ve made it through a pandemic, fires, power outages, SO much broken equipment, a smashed front door on Christmas Day & a lot of stressful times. But we’re stronger than ever with an awesome team, both past & present, and loads of engaging, enthusiastic customers. Beyond grateful 💫.

On the personal side, since we’ve opened, Michael & I got married. We had two beautiful babies. Our lives have changed a lot, but Bagel Mill has always been at the center of it. We hope to be mixing bagels, milling flour, pouring lattes and chatting with you for 7 more years & beyond!

07/01/2026

What’s Pavel’s favorite sandwich?! 🥁

The Jorge Special on a Black Pepper Parmesan Bagel (available Mondays only! 😍)

Our line cooks know what’s up—after all, they’re the ones creating your sandwiches every day. This spicy favorite is loaded with sautéed jalapeños and our signature sriracha mayo for the perfect kick. 🌶️🔥

Before the Jorge Special became a permanent menu item, it started as our Lead Line Cook Jorge’s go-to staff meal. We all kept ordering it for lunch after seeing him make it, and it quickly became a team favorite. It was too good not to share with everyone!

📸 Dylan Pacio

06/18/2026

Bagel dogs and bacon sticky buns for Dad! 🌭🥓

Celebrate Dad this weekend with two of our favorite specials: jalapeño cheddar bagel dogs and our irresistible bacon sticky buns. The perfect combination of savory, sweet, and just a little bit indulgent. Pre-order now before they sell out.

Stop by on Sunday and make Dad’s day a little more delicious!

06/13/2026

What is Assistant Manager Jake’s go-to sandwich? 🥁

Tuna salad on a double-toasted Black Pepper Parmesan bagel, topped with pickles and bacon. 🥒🥓

Our menu is endlessly customizable. Just when we think we’ve tried every possible combination, someone comes up with a new favorite! 🤩

06/05/2026

Okay burger lovers… this one’s for you! 🍔🍔🍔

We’re serving up TWO new Bagel Burger Specials for a limited time:

🍔 Classic Bagel Burger
1/3 lb beef patty, lettuce, tomato, red onion, pickles, ketchup & mustard

🍔🍳🥓 Breakfast Bagel Burger
A 1/3 lb cheeseburger topped with a bacon, egg & cheese

Available for a limited time only! Kick off summer with a burger on a bagel and try the combo you didn’t know you needed 😎☀️🔥

Address

212 Western Avenue
Petaluma, CA
94952

Opening Hours

Monday	7am - 2pm
Tuesday	7am - 2pm
Wednesday	7am - 2pm
Thursday	7am - 2pm
Friday	7am - 2pm
Saturday	7am - 2pm
Sunday	7am - 2pm

Telephone

+17079818010

Website

http://www.thebagelmill.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Bagel Mill Petaluma posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Bagel Mill Petaluma:

Shortcuts

Address
Telephone
Opening Hours
Alerts
Contact The Business
Claim ownership or report listing

Want your business to be the top-listed Restaurant in Petaluma?