The Pie

The Pie The Pie is one of the few locations on Long Island that serves authentic coal fired pizza and the only place to get pizza this unique. Open Daily at 11:30 am!
(496)

We are located on Main Street, just a short walk from the Marina. The Pie is one of the few locations on Long Island that serves authentic coal fired pizza and the ONLY place to get pizza this unique! When the Summer months hit, Port Jefferson Village is jumping and the hottest spot in town is The Pie! Whether you're part of our local community or just visiting, our family friendly atmosphere is t

he place to be. Our pizza is created thin, well done and crispy. Each pie is made with only the freshest ingredients served by our courteous staff. A great selection of appetizers, fresh salads, homemade pastas and desserts, are all part of our ambitious menu. We are located on Main Street, just a short walk from the Marina.

This is what family-style looks like at ✨Fresh. Flavor-packed. Served with love. Whether you’re craving pizza, pasta, ...
06/20/2025

This is what family-style looks like at ✨

Fresh. Flavor-packed. Served with love. Whether you’re craving pizza, pasta, or a little bit of everything—we’ve got your table covered. 🍕🍝🥗

Celebrate Dad your way—inside or under the sky. 🍷🍝🍕 Join us at TODAY for Father’s Day with coal-fired pizza, handmade ...
06/15/2025

Celebrate Dad your way—inside or under the sky. 🍷🍝🍕 Join us at TODAY for Father’s Day with coal-fired pizza, handmade pasta, and the perfect table—whether it’s indoors or on our beautiful patio.

Pasta, pizza, and the man of the hour. 🍝🍕🍷Celebrate this Father’s Day with bold, coal-fired flavors and family-style com...
06/13/2025

Pasta, pizza, and the man of the hour. 🍝🍕🍷
Celebrate this Father’s Day with bold, coal-fired flavors and family-style comfort. Because Dad deserves a spread as strong as he is. 💪

Start your week with a slice of something special 🍕 Mondays call for bold flavors, fresh ingredients, and pies worth slo...
06/09/2025

Start your week with a slice of something special 🍕 Mondays call for bold flavors, fresh ingredients, and pies worth slowing down for:

✨ Melanzana Pie – eggplant, roasted peppers, mushrooms, tomato sauce & mozzarella

🦐 Shrimp or Clam Pie – garlic, white wine, toasted breadcrumbs, mozzarella

🍄 Baby Bella – wild mushrooms, spinach, ricotta, truffle oil & mozzarella

Your table’s waiting 👀

Weekend plans: eat well, end sweet. Celebrate National Ice Cream Day at with a tartufo or a brownie sundae (or both—no...
06/08/2025

Weekend plans: eat well, end sweet. Celebrate National Ice Cream Day at with a tartufo or a brownie sundae (or both—no judgment). 🍒🍨

Cheese pulls. Coal-fired crust. Pure happiness. 🧀🔥 Celebrate National Cheese Day the right way at 🍕 ...
06/04/2025

Cheese pulls. Coal-fired crust. Pure happiness. 🧀🔥 Celebrate National Cheese Day the right way at 🍕

This one’s made for sharing… if you can 👀Nutella S’mores Pie, roasted marshmallows, graham crackers, and all the nostalg...
06/02/2025

This one’s made for sharing… if you can 👀
Nutella S’mores Pie, roasted marshmallows, graham crackers, and all the nostalgic feels 🍫🔥

Start strong. Stay craving at 🍽️🔥From the fresh baked clams 🦪 to the golden crunch of mozzarella sticks 🧀 and the bold...
05/31/2025

Start strong. Stay craving at 🍽️🔥

From the fresh baked clams 🦪 to the golden crunch of mozzarella sticks 🧀 and the bold, juicy heat of our coal-fired wings 🍗 these appetizers set the tone for an unforgettable meal!

Celebrate Memorial Day weekend the way it should be, with family, fresh air, and coal-fired favorites with us 🍕🌿 Our out...
05/24/2025

Celebrate Memorial Day weekend the way it should be, with family, fresh air, and coal-fired favorites with us 🍕🌿 Our outdoor dining is open and perfect for making memories around the table.

Gather your loved ones and let us do the cooking!

20 years strong, and still hand-tossing every pie with passion!🍕From the stretch ➡️ to the oven ➡️ to your table, this i...
05/23/2025

20 years strong, and still hand-tossing every pie with passion!🍕

From the stretch ➡️ to the oven ➡️ to your table, this is what true coal-fired tradition looks like.

✨ Perfect for big dinner parties.
🔥 The only coal-fired, independently owned pizzeria of its kind in the county.
🌿 Not just pizza…an experience.

Address

216 Main Street
Port Jefferson, NY
11777

Opening Hours

Monday 11:30am - 9:30pm
Tuesday 11:30am - 9:30pm
Wednesday 11:30am - 9:30pm
Thursday 11:30am - 9:30pm
Friday 11:30am - 10pm
Saturday 11:30am - 10pm
Sunday 11:30am - 9:30pm

Telephone

+16313314646

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Pie posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Pie:

Shortcuts

Share

Category