Tortuga Sandwich Shop

07/15/2026

It has been a great 6 years. Unfortunately, we are going to have to close down here in Sanborn. Our rent was just increased an additional $250 per month which is not affordable for us. I told the landlord that we will be out by the end of August. Our last service here in Sanborn will be sometime before then. Fortunately, we have been working on getting our dormant Kenmore location back up and running. We should be able to shut down Sanborn and open up Kenmore pretty seamlessly. I don’t have all the details yet but I will provide an update soon. I’m very sorry that we are leaving Sanborn. I live here and am blown away by the support the community here has given us. Once we do open, I hope some of you can make it out to visit us sometime. Thank you all!

07/06/2026

07/03/2026

It’s too hot to cook today. Come grab a sandwich! •
•
•
•
•

07/01/2026

This was off the menu for a while but it it back! The Choripan. Argentine chorizo, chimichurri, garlic aioli, fresh tomato salsa and pickled red onions all served on warm ciabatta. Come get one today!
•
•
•
•

07/01/2026

Come on and get yourself some sandwiches at Tortuga. Our food has electrolytes

06/24/2026

One of our all-time bestsellers is The Gustavo… and yes, it’s basically a flavor explosion wearing a sandwich costume.
Crispy fried chicken gets absolutely slathered in spicy chipotle butter (it’s having a moment), then piled on toasted ciabatta with melty Jack cheese, creamy avocado, sassy pickled onions & jalapeños, fresh tomato salsa, smoky chipotle Brava mayo, jalapeño ranch that brings the heat, and crisp romaine that’s just there to pretend it’s healthy.
One bite and you’ll be speaking fluent Gustavo. Come get one today before it sells out and breaks your heart! 🔥😂.

06/17/2026

Behold, The Chino, our Peruvian steak sandwich. Marinated sirloin steak, sautéed onions, cheese sauce, aji Amarillo mayo, fresh tomato salsa and crispy potato sticks on French bread.

06/16/2026

Meet the Ernesto. Braised shredded brisket, garlic aioli, provolone cheese, sautéed onions and crispy potato sticks all served on our French bread and breaded on our griddle until melted and crispy. Now available as part of our new menu. Come get one today!

06/13/2026

One of our most popular sandwiches is the Ybor. Mojo roast pork, smoked ham, Manchego cheese, dill pickles and dijonnaise on French bread and pressed until melted and crispy. Is it one of the best Cuban sandwiches in WNY?? That’s not for me to say..,but Yes