10/30/2026
Sorry for the long caption! 😂 Is Grande Cheese really THAT much better? 🍕🤔
A couple weeks ago, I met a representative from Grande Cheese at the Gordon Food Show and the Columbus Pizza Expo. We’ve been talking about getting together and trying their cheese on our pizzas ever since.
If you know anything about the pizza industry, you’ve probably heard of Grande. They’ve got a reputation for making some of the best pizza cheese money can buy.
And I’ve been skeptical.
I mean, how much better could it really be? Cheese is cheese, right? 😂
Well, today we finally put it to the test.
And I’ll give them credit. I do think Grande is better.
But was it this astronomical, mind-blowing difference that I was expecting to experience after hearing how great it was?
No. Not even close.
Honestly, the two cheeses were remarkably similar.
Now, there’s one important difference between the two products that I think is worth talking about.
Grande doesn’t use preservatives or anti-caking agents in its cheese. The cheese we’re currently using does contain additives that help prevent clumping and mold growth.
Before anybody gets too excited about that, if you’ve ever bought a bag of shredded cheese at the grocery store, there’s a pretty good chance you’ve eaten the same kinds of ingredients.
And we’re not talking about something particularly scary here. Anti-caking agents can be made from natural plant fibers, and certain mold inhibitors are produced through natural fermentation. These are common food ingredients, and there’s no reason to be terrified of them.
They’re just not cheese.
That’s really the distinction.
They’re added for a purpose. They help shredded cheese stay separated, improve its shelf life, and make it easier to store and distribute.
And those are legitimate benefits, especially when you’re producing and distributing food on a large scale.
Grande has chosen to leave those ingredients out, which is part of how they’ve positioned themselves as a premium cheese. One of the tradeoffs can be a shorter shelf life, but you’re getting a product without those additional ingredients.
And I respect that. Given the choice, I’d generally prefer fewer ingredients, too.
But I also don’t want anyone getting the wrong impression about our current cheese. It’s REAL cheese, made from 100% Michigan milk. There’s no filler in it, despite how that word sometimes gets thrown around when comparing these products.
So back to the actual taste test.
Here’s the funny part.
When you’ve got a sales rep standing there telling you how incredible his cheese is, there’s almost this pressure to agree with him. 😂
It’s like test-driving a car with the salesman sitting next to you, waiting for you to tell him how amazing it is.
You almost feel bad saying, “Yeah, it’s nice, but it’s not THAT much nicer.”
But I stuck to my guns.
I went into this skeptical, and I wasn’t going to pretend my mind was blown when it wasn’t.
If I had to put a completely unscientific number on it, I’d say Grande was maybe 10% better.
It had an ever-so-slightly cleaner taste. And I mean SLIGHTLY.
I consider myself to have a pretty keen palate, and even I almost got it wrong. I’m not entirely convinced I didn’t just get lucky. 😂
I genuinely believe that if we lined up a bunch of people and did a blind taste test, a lot of them wouldn’t even be able to identify which cheese was which.
That’s how close they were.
Now, don’t get me wrong. I DO think Grande was better. And with fewer ingredients, I think there’s a good reason to expect a slightly cleaner flavor.
But it wasn’t some life-changing experience.
And here’s where the real dilemma comes in.
Switching to Grande would mean adding roughly another $1 to the price of every large pizza.
And honestly, a dollar isn’t that much money.
But when I started Ryse Pizza, I didn’t set out to make the most expensive pizza imaginable. I wanted to make really good pizza that ordinary families could afford.
I wanted to give people something substantially better than what they’re getting from the big chains without charging an arm and a leg for it.
And I think we’ve done that.
But here’s what I’m wrestling with.
What if I could make your pizza just a little bit better, even if most people wouldn’t consciously notice the difference?
Is that worth another dollar?
Because I’m absolutely willing to explore switching to Grande. I’m not opposed to spending more money on a better ingredient.
But I also don’t want to start raising prices just because somebody convinced me that I needed to use the most expensive version of everything.
At some point, value matters.
So I’m genuinely curious what you guys think.
Would you rather pay another dollar for a large pizza knowing we’re using a slightly better cheese with fewer ingredients?
Or would you rather we keep using the really good Michigan-made cheese we’re already using and continue trying to keep our prices as affordable as possible?
I’m not saying one answer is right and the other is wrong.
I really am interested in hearing what our customers value.
And thank you to Grande for coming out and letting us put their cheese to the test! 🍕