Shelter Island SLICE

07/25/2026

Guess who’s going to be throwing the first pitch today?!

07/20/2026

Warning: Side effects of Trivia Night may include:

🍕 Eating too much pizza
😂 Laughing with friends
🏆 Bragging rights
🤓 Random facts you’ll never forget

Join us Wednesday at 6 PM and put your knowledge to the test!

07/17/2026

This. And nowhere else to be.

Tag the person who’s meeting you at the beach for dinner!

07/12/2026

Slice on a Sunday is always a good idea.

07/07/2026

Time to dust off the holiday weekend and put those brain cells to work! 🇺🇸✨ Trivia is back tomorrow night! 🎉🧠

Tag your trivia team below and we’ll see you at the Slice! 🍕🍻🏆

07/01/2026

06/16/2026

Trivia is back tomorrow night! 🎉🧠

Join us at 6 PM for pizza, drinks, laughs, and a little friendly competition. 🍕🏆

Tag your trivia team and we’ll see you at the Slice!

06/13/2026

🦌⚾️ HOME OPENER TODAY! ⚾️🦌

Sag Harbor Whalers vs. Shelter Island Bucks
📅 Saturday, June 13
⏰ 5:00 PM
📍 Fiske Field

🙌 Support the Bucks and cheer on the home team! 👕 Buy Bucks merch at the game and receive 🍕 10% OFF a pizza pie at Shelter Island Slice!

06/10/2026

We’re taking a break from Trivia Night this week, but we’re is still serving up all your favorites. 🍕🍻

Stop by for a slice, grab dinner with friends, and enjoy a laid-back island evening with us. We’ll be back to testing your knowledge before you know it!

See you at the counter. ❤️