Costello's Pizzeria

Costello's Pizzeria Costello's Pizzeria is located at 45 S New York Road in the Smithville section of Galloway Township.!

We are open year-round and offer Dine in, pick up & local deliveries orders.

The rain’s finally gone… fuggedabboudit 🤌☀️🍕Beautiful weather calls for an even better pizza. Our Fuggedabboudit is load...
05/28/2026

The rain’s finally gone… fuggedabboudit 🤌☀️🍕

Beautiful weather calls for an even better pizza. Our Fuggedabboudit is loaded with homemade marinara sauce, pepperoni, sausage, onions, mushrooms, red bell peppers, black olives & extra mozzarella cheese.

Available in small, medium, or large — because sunshine and pizza just go together.

Our Chicken Vodka Parmesan Pizza has officially become a customer favorite for a reason 🍕🔥A large 16” pie topped with ou...
05/27/2026

Our Chicken Vodka Parmesan Pizza has officially become a customer favorite for a reason 🍕🔥
A large 16” pie topped with our homemade vodka sauce, crispy breaded chicken cutlet & loads of melted mozzarella cheese. Simple, classic, and seriously addictive. 🤌

One bite and you’ll see why everyone keeps coming back for it 👀

🇺🇸 Memorial Day Weekend calls for great food, good company & honoring those who served. ❤️🤍💙Whether you’re spending the ...
05/23/2026

🇺🇸 Memorial Day Weekend calls for great food, good company & honoring those who served. ❤️🤍💙

Whether you’re spending the weekend at the shore, with family, or catching up with friends — let Costello’s handle the cooking 🍕🍗🥖

Pizza • Wings • Subs available at all 3 locations!
📍Smithville
📍Hammonton
📍The Nest

Wishing everyone a safe, relaxing & memorable holiday weekend! 🇺🇸

Planning a party, office lunch, graduation, or weekend get together? Let us handle the food 🍽️🔥A few catering favorites:...
05/19/2026

Planning a party, office lunch, graduation, or weekend get together? Let us handle the food 🍽️🔥

A few catering favorites:

🥖 Assorted Sub Trays (small or large)
Featuring ham, turkey, Italian, & homemade tuna salad

🥗 Blackened Chicken Bruschetta Salad (16” or 20” trays)
Mixed greens topped with blackened chicken, homemade bruschetta & fresh mozzarella

These are just a few of the options available — we’ve got plenty more on our full catering menu on our website 🙌 Fresh food, generous portions, and something for everyone!

Big things happening in Smithville Square 👀Be sure to stop by and check out our new neighbors! .smithville Open daily fr...
05/17/2026

Big things happening in Smithville Square 👀
Be sure to stop by and check out our new neighbors! .smithville Open daily from 7am–2pm serving up the perfect way to start your morning 🍳☕️🥪

We love seeing more local businesses join the community — show them some love! 💚

Sun’s out, the pizzas hot & we’re not too far☀️Swing by Costello’s at our new home — 45 S New York Road for pizza, wings...
05/16/2026

Sun’s out, the pizzas hot & we’re not too far☀️
Swing by Costello’s at our new home — 45 S New York Road for pizza, wings, subs & all your favorites. Beautiful weather, good food, even better vibes 🍕🔥

Fresh, colorful, and loaded from crust to corner 🍕🌱Our Da Veggie Pizza is stacked with broccoli, tomatoes, spinach, brea...
05/15/2026

Fresh, colorful, and loaded from crust to corner 🍕🌱
Our Da Veggie Pizza is stacked with broccoli, tomatoes, spinach, breaded eggplant, whipped ricotta & mozzarella cheese for the perfect veggie bite. Available in small, medium, or large!

A little sweet, a little spicy, and packed with flavor 🍋🌶️🍝Our Chicken Scarpariello features sautéed chicken, sweet Ital...
05/14/2026

A little sweet, a little spicy, and packed with flavor 🍋🌶️🍝

Our Chicken Scarpariello features sautéed chicken, sweet Italian sausage, white wine, capers, lemon slices & hot cherry peppers served over your choice of pasta. The perfect balance of bold Italian flavors in every bite. 🇮🇹🔥

Keeping it classic never goes out of style 🤌🥖Our Regular Italian is stacked on a fresh seeded roll from Rando’s Bakery —...
05/12/2026

Keeping it classic never goes out of style 🤌🥖

Our Regular Italian is stacked on a fresh seeded roll from Rando’s Bakery — but the best part? Every sub starts with just the meats & cheese so you can build it exactly how you like it. Lettuce, tomato, onions, oil, mayo, hot peppers… make it your own every time 🔥

Happy Mother’s Day from all of us at Costello’s 💐❤️Today we celebrate all the amazing moms, grandmoms, stepmoms, dog mom...
05/10/2026

Happy Mother’s Day from all of us at Costello’s 💐❤️

Today we celebrate all the amazing moms, grandmoms, stepmoms, dog moms, and mother figures who do so much for everyone around them every single day. Thank you for the love, strength, support & endless sacrifices you make.

We hope your day is filled with family, happiness, and of course… good food 🍕🐔

With love,
Costello’s

🚨 WE’RE HIRING AT ALL 3 LOCATIONS! 🚨Costello’s Smithville • Costello’s at The Nest • HammontonWe’re looking to add hardw...
05/09/2026

🚨 WE’RE HIRING AT ALL 3 LOCATIONS! 🚨

Costello’s Smithville • Costello’s at The Nest • Hammonton

We’re looking to add hardworking, dependable people to our team for:
🍕 Counter Staff
🚗 Delivery Drivers

If you’re energetic, team-oriented, and ready to work in a fast paced environment, we’d love to meet you!

✅ Flexible schedules
✅ Competitive pay
✅ Fun team atmosphere

Stop in and apply in person or message us for more details!
Come grow with the Costello’s family 🍗🍕

Address

45 South New York Road
Smithville, NJ
08205

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 10pm
Tuesday 11am - 10pm
Wednesday 11am - 10pm
Thursday 11am - 10pm
Friday 11am - 10pm
Saturday 11am - 10pm
Sunday 11am - 10pm

Telephone

+16096520378

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Costello's Pizzeria posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Costello's Pizzeria:

Shortcuts

Share

Category