Bennys Pizza

Bennys Pizza Voted best pizza in the Hudson Valley! For over 25 years, Benny's Pizzeria has served our community,

🏆🥍 From all of us at the pizzeria, we'd like to send a HUGE congratulations to the Rondout Valley Varsity Girls Lacrosse...
05/29/2026

🏆🥍 From all of us at the pizzeria, we'd like to send a HUGE congratulations to the Rondout Valley Varsity Girls Lacrosse Team on winning the Section 9 Class C Championship! 🥍🏆

What an incredible accomplishment! Your hard work, determination, teamwork, and dedication throughout the season have paid off in a big way.

We are proud to support our local athletes and celebrate this outstanding achievement with our community. Congratulations to the players, coaches, families, and fans who helped make this championship season possible!

Way to make Rondout Valley proud! 💙💛

🚨 HELP WANTED 🚨We’re looking to add to our team!Now hiring:🍕 Counter Help🚗 Delivery Drivers🍽️ Dishwasher✔ Fast-paced, fr...
05/27/2026

🚨 HELP WANTED 🚨

We’re looking to add to our team!

Now hiring:
🍕 Counter Help
🚗 Delivery Drivers
🍽️ Dishwasher

✔ Fast-paced, friendly environment
✔ Must have flexible availability
✔ Weekends and evenings preferred
✔ MUST be dependable

***NOT looking for a temporary or summer only employee

Stop in to fill out an application. Please no calls.

🔥 Two pies. Two completely different moods. Which one are you grabbing first? 👀🍕🤍 Our Fresh Mozzarella & Parmesan Reggia...
05/16/2026

🔥 Two pies. Two completely different moods. Which one are you grabbing first? 👀🍕

🤍 Our Fresh Mozzarella & Parmesan Reggiano Sicilian — crispy crust, rich tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, finished with imported Parmesan Reggiano and a drizzle of olive oil. Simple, classic, perfect.

🌶️ Our Jalapeño Pepperoni Pie — loaded with pepperoni and fresh jalapeños for the perfect spicy kick 🔥

Mild or spicy… there’s no wrong answer at Benny’s 😎

Available by the slice or as a whole pie! Stop in and try them today 👇

🔥 Meet the sandwich that became a pizza.🔥Our NEW Pastrami & Swiss Pie is loaded with thin-sliced pastrami, melted Swiss,...
05/16/2026

🔥 Meet the sandwich that became a pizza.🔥

Our NEW Pastrami & Swiss Pie is loaded with thin-sliced pastrami, melted Swiss, and topped your way — classic or piled high with or without sauerkraut 🤤

Served with a side of spicy brown mustard for the full deli experience!

Grab it by the slice OR order a whole pie for the table 🍕👀

One bite and you’ll be wondering why nobody thought of this sooner. Available for a limited time at Benny’s! 👇

🎓🍕 Future nurses fueled by Benny’s!Today, 5 out of 23 of the SUNY Ulster Nursing graduates stopped by Benny’s after grad...
05/15/2026

🎓🍕 Future nurses fueled by Benny’s!

Today, 5 out of 23 of the SUNY Ulster Nursing graduates stopped by Benny’s after graduation rehearsal for some well-earned lunch and sweet treats 💉🩺❤️

We’re honored you chose us to celebrate this exciting milestone. Congratulations to the entire nursing class — the future is in good hands! 👏

And thank you for the kind words:

“The best pizza around and even better hospitality!”

Good luck and congrats to all the grads from Benny and the crew! 🍕🎉

Happy Mother’s Day to all the amazing moms out there 💐We’re so thankful for all the love, support, and memories shared i...
05/10/2026

Happy Mother’s Day to all the amazing moms out there 💐

We’re so thankful for all the love, support, and memories shared in our pizza shop over the years. Wishing every mom a day full of love, laughs, and of course… pizza 🍕💕

Rainy day = perfect pizza weather ☔🍕Nothing beats a hot slice and comfort food when the weather looks like this. Stop in...
05/09/2026

Rainy day = perfect pizza weather ☔🍕

Nothing beats a hot slice and comfort food when the weather looks like this. Stop in, dry off, and grab your favorites — the case is loaded today 👀🍕

Which slice are you reaching for first?👇

Cinco de Mayo AND Taco Tuesday? Now that’s a party 🌮🍕Our Nacho Pizza is piled high with chili, fresh lettuce, tomatoes, ...
05/05/2026

Cinco de Mayo AND Taco Tuesday? Now that’s a party 🌮🍕

Our Nacho Pizza is piled high with chili, fresh lettuce, tomatoes, onions, banana peppers, sour cream, and melty cheddar cheese 🤩🔥

Tag someone who needs to split this pie with you 🍕

⚠️ Only available as a whole pie!

🏆🍕 Athlete of the Month Spotlight! 🍕🏆We’re proud to support the incredible student-athletes of the Rondout Valley Centra...
04/26/2026

🏆🍕 Athlete of the Month Spotlight! 🍕🏆

We’re proud to support the incredible student-athletes of the Rondout Valley Central School District 💪 We have been long supporters of these athletes for many years.

Each month, we recognize 3 Athletes of the Month who’s putting in the hard work, showing dedication, and representing their team and community the right way 👏

And because hard work deserves a reward…
🍕 Each Athlete of the Month receives a FREE pie on us! 🍕

It’s our way of giving back to the athletes who give it their all—on and off the field.

Keep grinding, keep pushing, and keep making Rondout Valley proud 💙🖤

🔥🍕 SMOKEHOUSE SPECIAL — YOU DON’T WANT TO MISS THIS 🍕🔥This isn’t just a pizza… this is a full-on BBQ takeover 🤤🔥We’re ta...
04/24/2026

🔥🍕 SMOKEHOUSE SPECIAL — YOU DON’T WANT TO MISS THIS 🍕🔥

This isn’t just a pizza… this is a full-on BBQ takeover 🤤🔥

We’re talking slow, tender BBQ brisket piled high, loaded with rich, melty Grande cheddar, topped with fresh red onion for that perfect bite of sweet, smoky, tangy, and a little crunch 👌

It’s messy. It’s bold. It’s the kind of slice you think about after you leave 😏

👉 By the slice OR whole pie (medium & large)

Here’s the catch… we honestly don’t know how long this one’s staying. When it’s gone, it may be gone or if it’s a big hit, it may be here to stay.

Don’t be the one hearing about it after the fact… come try it NOW 🔥

Tag your crew ⬇️

Address

3835 Main Street
Stone Ridge, NY
12484

Opening Hours

Monday 10:30am - 9pm
Tuesday 10:30am - 9pm
Wednesday 10:30am - 9pm
Thursday 10:30am - 10pm
Friday 10:30am - 10pm
Saturday 10:30am - 11pm
Sunday 10:30am - 10pm

Telephone

+18456874243

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Bennys Pizza posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category