Valley Subs Plus

Valley Subs Plus Just two people with one oven and a simple menu, celebrating 10 years of business! Pro ordering tip: Call Early! Phone lines get busy and sell outs happen!
(1)

Area's first: Old Forge Pizza, Calzone, Sweetie Pie (sweet, sweet garlic 🍕) and Italian Grinder.

07/21/2026

Wednesday Specials below and a sneak peek of this week's bakery items

*Featured Free Topping: SAUSAGE

$12 Medium/$15 Large
Italian Stromboli OR Calzone

$25 Whole Tray Old Forge + Large NY

Sneak peak at some of this week's dessert flavors! OPEN this week Wednesday-Saturday, CLOSED SUNDAY. PRE-ORDERS always a...
07/20/2026

Sneak peak at some of this week's dessert flavors! OPEN this week Wednesday-Saturday, CLOSED SUNDAY. PRE-ORDERS always appreciated, but not necessary.

Sunday Specials, pre-orders not required, but appreciated $11 Large NY$15 Medium NY + 1 cake$16 Large Italian Stromboli ...
07/19/2026

Sunday Specials, pre-orders not required, but appreciated

$11 Large NY
$15 Medium NY + 1 cake
$16 Large Italian Stromboli
$20 Large NY + 2 cakes
$20 Large Italian Stromboli + 1 cake
$20 TWO Large NY
$35 Large Italian Stromboli + 2 Large NY
$40 TWO Large NY + 4 cakes

We have power and are still taking orders, call now!
07/18/2026

We have power and are still taking orders, call now!

Saturday SpecialsBuy any Large Pizza, get $3 off Large Buffalo Bites Buy any Medium Pizza, get $1.50 off Small Buffalo A...
07/18/2026

Saturday Specials

Buy any Large Pizza, get $3 off Large Buffalo Bites

Buy any Medium Pizza, get $1.50 off Small Buffalo

And Kailee brought more Cinnamon Swirl Cake! So if you missed out last night, call early today and reserve a few. They sell out fast! (No Pizza purchase necessary)

Need a dessert for your upcoming event? Click the blue and message kailee! Sugar & Spice Bakery

Friday DATE NIGHT Specials $13 6 cuts + 1 Cinnamon Swirl $17Medium Italian Stromboli OR Calzone + 1 Cinnamon Swirl$25 La...
07/17/2026

Friday DATE NIGHT Specials

$13
6 cuts + 1 Cinnamon Swirl

$17
Medium Italian Stromboli OR Calzone + 1 Cinnamon Swirl

$25
Large Italian Stromboli OR Calzone + 2 Cinnamon Swirl

$25
12 cuts + 2 Cinnamon Swirl

07/16/2026

Not sold out yet!
Still taking orders!
Let's make a deal!
Call now

Thursday Specials$5 Cinnamon Swirl Cake by Sugar & Spice Bakery $15 Medium NY + 1 cake $20 Large NY + 2 cakes$18 Medium ...
07/16/2026

Thursday Specials

$5 Cinnamon Swirl Cake by Sugar & Spice Bakery

$15 Medium NY + 1 cake

$20 Large NY + 2 cakes

$18 Medium NY + Small Buffalo Bite

$22 Large NY + Large Buffalo Bite

$4-6 Other Assorted Bakery Items

Wednesday's Specials $8.99 - 6 cuts, with or without onion$12/$15 Medium/Large Italian Stromboli orCalzone$27.98 - 24 cu...
07/15/2026

Wednesday's Specials

$8.99 - 6 cuts, with or without onion

$12/$15 Medium/Large
Italian Stromboli or
Calzone

$27.98 - 24 cuts, with or without onion

This Week's featured cake:
Cinnamon Swirl by Sugar & Spice Bakery

And....Cookies! Kailee is restocking the bakery rack! Check out her page for a sneak peak of available cookie flavors.

Wednesday's Specials $8.99 - 6 cuts, with or without onion$12/$15 Medium/Large Italian Stromboli orCalzone$27.98 - 24 cu...
07/14/2026

Wednesday's Specials

$8.99 - 6 cuts, with or without onion

$12/$15 Medium/Large
Italian Stromboli or
Calzone

$27.98 - 24 cuts, with or without onion

This Week's featured cake:
Cinnamon Swirl by Sugar & Spice Bakery

And....Cookies! Kailee is restocking the bakery rack! Check out her page for a sneak peak of flavors or to order directly!

Address

5355 Main Road
Sweet Valley, PA
18656

Opening Hours

Wednesday 4pm - 8pm
Thursday 4pm - 8pm
Friday 4pm - 8pm
Saturday 4pm - 8pm
Sunday 4pm - 8pm

Telephone

+15704772022

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Valley Subs Plus posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category