Valley Subs Plus

Call Directions

Valley Subs Plus ProOrderingTip:PRE-ORDER!We take phone orders anytime after 11am.Reserve your time slot,pickup/delivery begin 4pm W-Sun.

We're 2people,1oven and a simple menu,celebrating 10years of business!Areas first:OldForgePizza,Calzone,Sweetie Pie and ItalianGrinder

FRIDAY: Cheesecake, Plain or with Strawberry Open at 4. Call your order in anytime! PRE-ORDERS WELCOMED
10/30/2026

FRIDAY:
Cheesecake, Plain or with Strawberry

Open at 4. Call your order in anytime! PRE-ORDERS WELCOMED

Thursday Football Specials $9 Garlic Stix$25 Whole Tray Old Forge + Large NY PizzasNEW Buffalo Bite Flavor: HONEY BBQ
10/29/2026

Thursday Football Specials

$9 Garlic Stix
$25 Whole Tray Old Forge + Large NY Pizzas

NEW Buffalo Bite Flavor: HONEY BBQ

Sunday Football Specials $11 MacDaddy *Sirloin Steak and Cheese topped with Onion,         Lettuce, Tomato, Pickles and ...
10/25/2026

Sunday Football Specials

$11 MacDaddy
*Sirloin Steak and Cheese topped with Onion, Lettuce, Tomato, Pickles and Special Sauce

$26 TWO Whole Trays

Saturday, open at 4, taking orders NOW! Avoid the rush/sell out. Place your order early! Reserve your Pick-Up / Delivery...
10/24/2026

Saturday, open at 4, taking orders NOW! Avoid the rush/sell out. Place your order early! Reserve your Pick-Up / Delivery time. Times start at 4pm.

Dessert by Sugar & Spice Bakery :
Apple Spice Cake (these WILL sell out. Don't be shy, call ahead and secure your dessert!!!)

Friday Specials Open at 4, avoid the rush and pre-order NOW!$8.99 Garlic STIX$26 TWO WHOLE TRAYS
10/23/2026

Friday Specials
Open at 4, avoid the rush and pre-order NOW!

$8.99 Garlic STIX
$26 TWO WHOLE TRAYS

Thursday Football SpecialsTaking orders NOW, preorder and avoid the rushOpen at 4 for Pickup and Delivery $9.99 Medium N...
10/22/2026

Thursday Football Specials
Taking orders NOW, preorder and avoid the rush
Open at 4 for Pickup and Delivery

$9.99 Medium NY
$15.99 Medium NY White Deluxe
$17.99 Large NY Buffalo Chicken

Wednesday Specials $9 - Personal Plain or Pepperoni $12 - Personal Buffalo or CBR$15 - Large Italian Stromboli OR Calzon...
10/21/2026

Wednesday Specials

$9 - Personal Plain or Pepperoni
$12 - Personal Buffalo or CBR
$15 - Large Italian Stromboli OR Calzone

Sunday Specials Taking orders all day. Pick up and DELIVERY times start at 4pm.$20 - Large NY + 2 Pumpkin Spice Cake by ...
10/18/2026

Sunday Specials
Taking orders all day. Pick up and DELIVERY times start at 4pm.

$20 - Large NY + 2 Pumpkin Spice Cake by Sugar & Spice Bakery
$22 - 2 Large NY
$25 - Large NY + Whole Tray Old Forge

Friday SpecialOrder anytime after 11am. Pick-up and DELIVERY times starting at 4pm. WHITE DELUXE *No Sauce, All Cheese P...
10/16/2026

Friday Special
Order anytime after 11am. Pick-up and DELIVERY times starting at 4pm.

WHITE DELUXE
*No Sauce, All Cheese Pizza, topped with Ricotta, Tomato and Broccoli
$14 - 6 Cuts
$24 - 12 Cuts

Thursday Football SpecialsYou can preorder anytime after 11am, Pick-up and Delivery times from 4pm -8pm.$9 - 10" NY$9 Ch...
10/15/2026

Thursday Football Specials
You can preorder anytime after 11am, Pick-up and Delivery times from 4pm -8pm.

$9 - 10" NY

$9 Cheesy Breadsticks

$9 Stix & Cuts Combo Box

$13 - 10" NY CBR or Buffalo Chicken

Buy any Large Pizza, save $2 on Buffalo Chicken Bites

$25 Whole Tray + Large NY

Address

5355 Main Road
Sweet Valley, PA
18656

Opening Hours

Wednesday 4pm - 8pm
Thursday 4pm - 8pm
Friday 4pm - 8pm
Saturday 4pm - 8pm
Sunday 4pm - 8pm

Telephone

+15704772022

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Valley Subs Plus posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Nearby restaurants