Cafe DeWitt

Cafe DeWitt Voted Best Brunch of Ithaca 2005, 2008 & 2010 - Ithaca Times; Voted Best Breakfast in Ithaca 2015 - Ithaca Journal
(1)

Cafe DeWitt opened in 1973 as a small coffee shop for the residents of the then newly repurposed Ithaca High School building. The Cafe is the legacy of William Downing who had the vision to turn an old school building into a lively community of restaurants, stores, offices and apartments. Over the years the Cafe has expanded to offer an extensive breakfast and lunch menu featuring many locally and

regionally sourced ingredients that are lovingly prepared by Chef-Owners Denise O'Leary and Benjamin Roach. We are well known for our 3-time Best of Ithaca awarded weekend brunch that is bolstered my many rotating specials. Our staff is the heart of the business, they are constantly striving to deliver a welcoming dining experience that reflects the desire that we share to cook and serve with love.

Specials for this week and next! Got some gorgeous strawberries from Silver Queen Farm that we’re turning into an Eton m...
07/08/2026

Specials for this week and next! Got some gorgeous strawberries from Silver Queen Farm that we’re turning into an Eton mess pavlova - with barely sweetened whipped cream and so many fresh berries 🍓🍓🍓

And, if you’re a fan of the past, we’ve got a twist on the Michel sandwich from way back – brie, bacon, baby spinach, mayo, chutney – only this one is served on toasted sourdough and the chutney is of the rhubarb variety. Seasonal classic redux is the theme. Plus, salted honey cold brew latte! Chocolate pretzel pie! Come try them all! On through July 15 💗

🍳 BEAU (GF) - Omelette with curried potatoes, peas, bell peppers, mint chutney

🍒 TERRY - French Toast with cherry compote, whipped cream, toasted almonds (GF available)

🥪 BRIE - Sandwich with Brie, baby spinach, bacon, mayo, & rhubarb chutney on sourdough

🥗 ANYA (V & GF) - Mixed greens salad with lentils & carrot chutney, feta, orange supremes, pistachios, basil-tahini dressing

🍨 DESSERT SPECIALS
- Scone of the day
- Raspberry Brown Butter Muffin (GF)
- Chocolate Chess Pretzel Pie (GF)
with pretzel crust & served with whipped cream
- Eton Mess Pavlova (GF)
with fresh strawberries & whipped cream

🍹 DRINK SPECIALS
- Emmy Palmer - iced hibiscus tea + limeade
- Salted Honey Cold Brew Latte

We are OPEN normal hours Thursday 7/2 but with a few changes 🥵 We’re turning off the griddle to keep things cooler for o...
07/02/2026

We are OPEN normal hours Thursday 7/2 but with a few changes 🥵 We’re turning off the griddle to keep things cooler for our kitchen crew… however, we’ll still have plenty of eggs, breakfast sandwiches, toast & potatoes, plus non-pressed sandwiches and salads.

We’ve also got our full beverage & pastry menu available, plus some savory pastry specials – feta & dill scones, savory vegetable focaccia, and more.

Come visit us and enjoy the cool comfort that only a subterranean lagoon in a 112-year-old stone building can provide. We’ll keep the lemonade flowing.

Really excited to share an update for future FILIPINO FRIDAYS – 14Strings! will be performing LIVE at the cafe for our J...
06/30/2026

Really excited to share an update for future FILIPINO FRIDAYS – 14Strings! will be performing LIVE at the cafe for our July and August first friday evenings!

Come join us for an evening of Filipino food and music, featuring a special dinner menu by chef Denise O'Leary. Coconut shaved ice with tapioca & pandan jelly? Banh mi-style sandos with GARLIC LONGGANISA??? Okay YES. (Takeout also available!)

📍 Friday, July 3rd | 5-7pm

AND

📍 Friday, August 7th | 5-7pm

The Dewitt Mall
215 N. Cayuga St, Ithaca NY

Really excited to share an update for future FILIPINO FRIDAYS - 14Strings! will be performing LIVE at the cafe for our J...
06/30/2026

Really excited to share an update for future FILIPINO FRIDAYS - 14Strings! will be performing LIVE at the cafe for our July and August first friday evenings!

Come join us for an evening of Filipino food and music, featuring a special dinner menu by chef Denise O'Leary. Coconut shaved ice with tapioca & pandan jelly? Banh mi-style sandos with GARLIC LONGGANISA??? Okay YES. (Takeout also available!)

📍 Friday, July 3rd | 5-7pm

AND

📍 Friday, August 7th | 5-7pm

The Dewitt Mall
215 N. Cayuga St, Ithaca NY

Dessert specials 🍨 one more week of these! On through Thursday 7/2 💞💞💞
06/27/2026

Dessert specials 🍨 one more week of these! On through Thursday 7/2 💞💞💞

Some of our current specials, on through Thursday 7/2 🍳Frittata verde with asparagus, spinach, ricotta, caramelized onio...
06/27/2026

Some of our current specials, on through Thursday 7/2 🍳

Frittata verde with asparagus, spinach, ricotta, caramelized onions & thyme. Named for ARGOS, Odysseus’s dog in the Odyssey… and also for our faves Bar Argos 🍸

The BAWANG Filipino longganisa breakfast sandwich – garlicky pork sausage, pickled daikon, a fried egg, house sweet chili aioli & crispy fried garlic on a pillowy brioche bun.

And last but not least, the RHYS buttermilk waffle special, served with strawberry rhubarb jam, fresh whipped cream, and fresh local strawberries 🍓

New specials for the next two weeks! It was so much fun seeing you all at Taste of the Finger Lakes; we made more Filipi...
06/19/2026

New specials for the next two weeks! It was so much fun seeing you all at Taste of the Finger Lakes; we made more Filipino Longganisa except this time instead of meatballs, it’s a sausage patty in the most epic Filipino-inspired breakfast sandwich - garlicky, with a little sweet heat from sweet chili aioli, and the crisp crunch of pickled daikon radish. You don’t wanna miss this one. Plus, strawberry rhubarb buttermilk waffles, frittata packed with early summer produce, GF COWBOY COOKIES and a whole lot more.

🍳 BAWANG - Breakfast sandwich with Filipino Longganisa (garlic pork sausage), pickled daikon, fried egg, sweet chili aioli, fried garlic on a brioche bun

🧇 RHYS - Buttermilk waffle with strawberry rhubarb jam, whipped cream, fresh strawberries

🥬 ARGOS - Frittata with asparagus, spinach, ricotta, caramelized onions, thyme

🍨 DESSERT SPECIALS
- Rhubarb Streusel Muffin (GF)
- Banana Bread Scone
- Carrot Bundt Cake (dairy-free, contains egg)
- Cowboy Cookie (GF) - w/ chocolate chips, pecans, coconut & mini pretzels

🍹 DRINK SPECIALS
- Watermelon Mint Agua Fresca
- Rosemary Cold Brew Iced Latte

some of our current specials 🐟 on through 6/18!the BERNICE Niçoise salad - tuna poached gently in olive oil with herbs a...
06/11/2026

some of our current specials 🐟 on through 6/18!

the BERNICE Niçoise salad - tuna poached gently in olive oil with herbs and garlic, jammy eggs, string beans, kalamata olives, cherry tomatoes, on a bed of little gem lettuce from Plowbreak Farm with dijon vinaigrette

strawberry rhubarb crisp which is VEGAN and GLUTEN-FREE so really it’s very healthy and we recommend having some for breakfast with a dollop of yogurt, but we’re also serving it warm with a scoop of Cayuga Lake Creamery vanilla bean ice cream.

the SUZIE french toast special with sweet ricotta, blueberry sage compote, and cardamom streusel. If you yearn for the Sunday Brunch stuffed french toasts of yore – this is it!

Niçoise salad tuna looking like a million bucks

the CHESTER chorizo breakfast burrito special

blueberry lavender scones 💜

Just a few days left to try this round of specials! After June 3rd it’s on to a whole new selection.The DANE toast speci...
06/01/2026

Just a few days left to try this round of specials! After June 3rd it’s on to a whole new selection.

The DANE toast special has been so much fun to make – 100% spring goodness. Sesame sourdough from , topped with chicken breast marinated with yogurt & harissa, pickled red onions, Lively Run Dairy feta cheese, and gorgeous pea shoots from .

Plus we have the PAUL omelette – oyster mushrooms from , green garlic, ‘Interlaken’ goat’s milk cheddar. With a side salad of local Remembrance Farm field greens and made with eggs, this special is almost completely locally sourced!

Can’t forget the ASJA biscuits and gravy for .sparkles, with housemade biscuits (of course) and pork sausage.

Also, falafel special (have you tried ’s falafel salad? Incredible), peanut butter brownies, scones, rosemary lemonade 😮‍💨 and much more…

Gosh, aren’t we lucky to be cooking here in the Finger Lakes.

Address

215 N Cayuga Street
Ithaca, NY
14850

Opening Hours

Monday 8:30am - 2:30pm
Tuesday 9am - 2pm
Wednesday 9am - 5pm
Thursday 8:30am - 2:30pm
Friday 8:30am - 2:30pm
Saturday 8:30am - 2:30pm
Sunday 9am - 2pm

Telephone

+16072733473

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Cafe DeWitt posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Cafe DeWitt:

Shortcuts

Share

Category