The Cake Lady

The Cake Lady Custom desserts for every occasion! At least 2-week notice is required. Last-minute orders are based on availability. Desserts for all occasions!!

Order anytime at thecakeladyonline.net ✨

Thank you,
Sarah Haverstock-Owner Cheesecakes, Cupcakes, Cookies, Brownies, Strawberries, Cakes, Shooter Cups and lot more!!

SOLD OUT! It's Friday!! Open 11am-8pm or sold out. 🤩Cheesecake slices🎂Cake slices🍫Brownies🧁Tin cakes🍪Cookies🏡2475 E. Pie...
06/05/2026

SOLD OUT! It's Friday!! Open 11am-8pm or sold out.
🤩Cheesecake slices
🎂Cake slices
🍫Brownies
🧁Tin cakes
🍪Cookies
🏡2475 E. Pierceton Road Warsaw
💲Cash, cards, cash app, paypal, venmo, checks.
Cash box on the wall and qr codes on the table!

Saturday Cottage update- opening at 12pm on Saturday! Please do not come early. We have tons of custom order pick ups a...
06/04/2026

Saturday Cottage update- opening at 12pm on Saturday! Please do not come early. We have tons of custom order pick ups and need to keep the driveway open! Thank you everyone! ❤️

The Cottage is open!! Thursday 11AM-8PM OR sold out. Lots of goodies today!!Cheesecake, tin cakes, tres leches, cake...
06/04/2026

The Cottage is open!!
Thursday 11AM-8PM OR sold out. Lots of goodies today!!
Cheesecake, tin cakes, tres leches, cake slices, cupcake packs, sugar cookies, brownies, and strawberry shortcake!!

While the hubby is away for work, I will bake, bake, bake! 🧁💕The Cottage will be open Thursday, Friday, 11am-8pm AND Sat...
06/01/2026

While the hubby is away for work, I will bake, bake, bake! 🧁💕
The Cottage will be open Thursday, Friday, 11am-8pm AND Saturday 12pm-8pm this week! OR SOLD OUT!🤩

Please bear with me as I have LOTS of custom orders along with keeping the Cottage stocked this week. I’m doing my best to keep up and make sure everything is fresh and delicious!

I appreciate all of your patience, support, and excitement — it truly means so much to this little small-batch bakery. ❤️ See you this week!
(And if I sell out, just know I’m over here baking as fast as these hands can go 😅)

Also, please do not block the driveway. You can park anywhere in the grass that your heart desires if the parking lot is full! Theres plenty of space for everyone! 😊

👏🥳Congratulations to the Class of 2026!! 🥳👏I have been slacking on taking pics of custom orders but I couldn't miss taki...
05/31/2026

👏🥳Congratulations to the Class of 2026!! 🥳👏
I have been slacking on taking pics of custom orders but I couldn't miss taking pics of these cupcakes!!🌻🌸🌹🌷

Custom order inquiries can be placed here- Thecakeladyonline.net ❤️

If you need bbq today this is it!! Im addicted!! Juicy , tender, perfect 👌 Uppercut Prime Meats And Grilling Supplies o...
05/30/2026

If you need bbq today this is it!! Im addicted!! Juicy , tender, perfect 👌 Uppercut Prime Meats And Grilling Supplies open til 4pm!!

Hey friends!! 💕The Cottage will be closed this week while we finish up landscaping and a few other projects to get every...
05/27/2026

Hey friends!! 💕
The Cottage will be closed this week while we finish up landscaping and a few other projects to get everything ready for summer!

While we’re working, I’d love your input!
✨ What are your favorite days to shop?
✨ What are your favorite things to get from The Cottage?
I can’t wait to hear what everyone loves most! 🩷

Also, my husband was able to work on the landscape before he leaves for Seattle!! Thank you everyone for your landscaper suggestions!

SOLD OUT!! WOW!! What a day!! 🥰 Friday open til sold out!Just a few dozen cupcake packs left!! Decorated in red, white, ...
05/22/2026

SOLD OUT!! WOW!! What a day!! 🥰 Friday open til sold out!
Just a few dozen cupcake packs left!! Decorated in red, white, and blue!

Thursday SOLD OUT!! REOPEN Friday at 11am!! Memorial day cupcake packs- vanilla and chocolate onlyCookies- sugar with sp...
05/21/2026

Thursday SOLD OUT!! REOPEN Friday at 11am!!
Memorial day cupcake packs
- vanilla and chocolate only
Cookies
- sugar with sprinkles
Cheesecake slices
And more!

SOLD OUT Thursday!! The Cottage is open!! Thursday and Friday 11am-8pm OR sold out!!Bundt cakes👌Dubai❤️Red velvet 🫐Lemon...
05/21/2026

SOLD OUT Thursday!! The Cottage is open!! Thursday and Friday 11am-8pm OR sold out!!
Bundt cakes
👌Dubai
❤️Red velvet
🫐Lemon Blueberry
🍋Lemon
🔥Raspberry lemon
🤩White reeses
💓Oreo
😋Biscoff
🥜Oreo peanut butter
🍫Triple chocolate
🥜Chocolate peanut butter

Tres leches
🍓Strawberry
🥰Oreo

Cheesecake cups- (no bake Cheesecake)
🥰Oreo
🍓Strawberry
🍋Lime
🫐Blueberry
👌Dubai
🥜Peanut butter
😍Biscoff

Brownies
🥜Peanut butter
👌Mint chip
🍫Ganache

Cookies
🥳Sugar
🍪Pecan chocolate chip
🍪M&M

And lots of chocolate dipped items!!

🏡2475 E. Pierceton Road
💲Cash, cards, venmo, paypal, cash app

Address

2475 E. Pierceton Road
Warsaw, IN
46580

Telephone

+15742532705

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Cake Lady posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Cake Lady:

Shortcuts

Share